News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU Floats Canada Becoming the Bloc's First 'Associate Mem... by cromka on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @04:28AM (#49723555)
I love that argument now parroted all over the Internet. Love it because what these people actually eman is they want an elected president, which would legitimize EU even more, hopefully with its own constitution.
Re:EU Floats Canada Becoming the Bloc's First 'Associate Mem... by freehorse on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @04:42AM (#49723668)
Not necessarily. One can eg want more power to the actually elected part of the EU structure and less power to the commission. Imo electing or not a president does not necessarily help with democracy, as the US example shows. And in europe most countries do not have a strong presidential system, except France and 2-3 others. So I doubt having "strong elected president" is what people actually have in mind for the EU.

People bring this up they may consider EU to be historically a centralized power structure. Whether it can practically be actually democratized or not is a matter of debate. One can bring up the democratic deficit of EU without harbouring actual thoughts or hopes that it can be fixed.

Re:EU Floats Canada Becoming the Bloc's First 'Associate Mem... by gizajob on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @04:31AM (#49723580)
That would be the next step but they seem to be getting on fine with an unelected president.
Re:EU Floats Canada Becoming the Bloc's First 'Associate Mem... by bawolff on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @04:31AM (#49723589)
EU already has a constitution (?)
Re:EU Floats Canada Becoming the Bloc's First 'Associate Mem... by mattashii on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @04:36AM (#49723624)
Nope, it doesn't. It's current legal basis is a series of treaties, the attempt to create a constitution failed when in 2005 the various countries' local referenda on supporting an EU constitution failed to garner the required support. FRA' referendum failed 45-55, and NLD's consultative referendum on June 1 also gave a solid "no" (38.5% yes vs 61.5% no).
Re:EU Floats Canada Becoming the Bloc's First 'Associate Mem... by bawolff on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @06:08AM (#49724263)
> It's current legal basis is a series of treaties

But that meets the normal definition of a constitution. Just because the document isn't named the "constitution" doesn't make it any less of one. Most countries have constitutions that look like EU's legal basis. America style constitutions are less common.

The later attempt to consolidate the constitution failing, doesn't make the previous legal basis any less of a constitution.

Re:EU Floats Canada Becoming the Bloc's First 'Associate Mem... by mattashii on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @07:59AM (#49725524)
That's fair criticism. The deeper reason why it's not a constitution is because it's not the cornerstone of legal, moral, and existential rights of the signatory constituent countries. These countries each have their own constitution that they are beholden to, with no higher authority to fall back to.

The Treaty of Maastricht (and later, Lisbon) can't be guaranteed to have precedence when called upon if they conflict with the constituent countries' constitution(s), and all legislation covered under the treaties must be implemented separately and completely as locally applicable laws before going into effect. The EU regulations generally prescribe a deadline for implementing such regulations, but a country could (and sometimes does, see e.g. Hungary under Orban) break its obligations under the Treaty and ignore or never implement the agreed-upon regulations, and the EU would be unable to do much to enforce its regulations.

Re:EU Floats Canada Becoming the Bloc's First 'Associate Mem... by gizajob on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @10:38AM (#49727746)
But as it’s proven time and time again, when there’s democratic pushback and rejection of its ideas, it just ignores the democracy and continues with the ideas regardless. The Lisbon treaty being rejected has just led to all its aims being implemented piecemeal anyway. And nobody in Europe asked for or voted for having a president, yet here is Ursula speaking for everyone today, again.
Re:EU Floats Canada Becoming the Bloc's First 'Associate Mem... by cromka on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @04:39AM (#49723648)
As others said. Constitution and an elected president would pave way into a common military.
Re:EU Floats Canada Becoming the Bloc's First 'Associate Mem... by freehorse on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @04:45AM (#49723701)
Yeah, good to make it clear that militarization of europe is what is actually debated, not democracy.
Re:EU Floats Canada Becoming the Bloc's First 'Associate Mem... by cromka on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @05:10AM (#49723853)
Who said that?