News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by catpower on Monday September 14, 2026 @10:50AM (#49697897)
Great short term achievement but humanity is better served by these kids doing it without AI. The ideas have to come from the next generation (eg would we be worried if a 5 year old wrote the great American novel with AI or not?)
Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by skybrian on Monday September 14, 2026 @11:53AM (#49699012)
I think it's more like how anyone learning to play chess is going to use chess engines, but you can't learn to play by always asking the chess engine for the answer.

I expect that all mathematicians are going to be working with power tools, so they might as well learn about that. They will still need to do math exercises by hand to learn the material.

Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by measurablefunc on Monday September 14, 2026 @10:56AM (#49697988)
AI is not going away so people will have to get used to it just like they will have to get used to it in software engineering. The alternative is being less productive than people who are happy to use AI to write software & do mathematical research.
Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by adamddev1 on Monday September 14, 2026 @11:41AM (#49698835)
A similar line of thought is used to justify corruption:

"Corruption is not going away so people will have to get used to it. The alternative is making less money than people who are happy to take bribes."

Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by btilly on Monday September 14, 2026 @12:21PM (#49699480)
The fact that a similar argument can be made does not mean that it is wrong.

Socrates famously made the opposing side of the argument against writing. Which is why we mostly know of him through Plato, who did believe in writing.

And to your corruption example. If you live in a society where corruption is normal and expected, you will be worse off if you are unwilling to be corrupt. It is indeed a local optima. But we are all, of course, better off if we live in a society where corruption is punished. To me, the worst thing about modern US politics, is that it's encouraging us to see ourselves as living in a world where corruption exists and is tolerated.

Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by measurablefunc on Monday September 14, 2026 @12:19PM (#49699452)
People used to complain about compilers as well.
Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by adamddev1 on Monday September 14, 2026 @12:50PM (#49699983)
Compilers are deterministic.
Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by measurablefunc on Monday September 14, 2026 @12:53PM (#49700055)
So are AI.
Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by adamddev1 on Monday September 14, 2026 @05:16PM (#49704164)
LLMs are probabilistic, not deterministic.
Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by measurablefunc on Monday September 14, 2026 @05:36PM (#49704445)
That is a very common misconception.
Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by selectodude on Monday September 14, 2026 @12:12PM (#49699332)
I can’t run a corruption racket in my basement.
Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by oasisaimlessly on Monday September 14, 2026 @11:13AM (#49698324)
It is still an unknown whether an unqualified increase in productivity in the long-term for software engineering is a given.
Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by qarl on Monday September 14, 2026 @11:17AM (#49698413)
Really? OK - then let me stand up and vouch that I am at least 20X more productive with AI.
Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by adamddev1 on Monday September 14, 2026 @11:44AM (#49698892)
Would I be wrong to assume that you are building end-user applications?

If people use AI for libraries, OSs, and mission critical software, the apparent productivity gains would have to be weighed against the reliability and performance hits that bubble up to the things that are built on them and rely on them.

Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by qarl on Monday September 14, 2026 @12:07PM (#49699251)
In my experience - a robust testing harness will get you the safety you need. And most software you describe has such testing.

I think the Bun port is a great example where testing enabled a very successful implementation. (Both the original tests themselves and runtime comparisons to the previous implementation.)

Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by adamddev1 on Monday September 14, 2026 @12:49PM (#49699964)
Testing is an extremely inadequate measure of reliability and robustness.
Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by qarl on Monday September 14, 2026 @01:11PM (#49700402)
You understand that robust testing can, should, and often does test directly for reliability and robustness, right?
Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by adamddev1 on Monday September 14, 2026 @05:14PM (#49704123)
Yes of course, but you also understand that as Dijkstra said "tests cannot show the absence of bugs."

Tests can show you problems, if you can find them, but they cannot show that there are no problems. Property based testing or fuzzing gets your more coverage, and is a good step, but it is still nothing compared to proving things or understanding how something is built and that it is solid. Testing works towards checking for reliability and robustness, but often it's only 10% (?) of the job.

Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by qarl on Monday September 14, 2026 @06:06PM (#49704846)
Well, yes, I understand that testing does not create a provably correct solution. But I'd love to hear the source of your "extremely inadequate" or your "10%" claims. I mean - there is a reason why it's used extensively in software engineering - right? Or don't you see value in that, either?

I'm curious - is there any data on the Bun port error rate? I think that would be very indicative of how successful or not the testing is.

Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by tom_ on Monday September 14, 2026 @11:30AM (#49698657)
In the long term, it'll be at least be the year 2030. Let's not get ahead of ourselves.
Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by dermacentor on Monday September 14, 2026 @11:28AM (#49698616)
In the long term.
Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by qarl on Monday September 14, 2026 @11:53AM (#49699030)
Fair enough - it will take some time before the science comes back.

But I feel the need to point out - the goalposts for "does AI work" shift daily.

Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by vouaobrasil on Monday September 14, 2026 @11:32AM (#49698681)
But isn't it a horrible thing that what you just described (being forced by the prisoner's dilemma), is what defines progress these days?
Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by measurablefunc on Monday September 14, 2026 @12:10PM (#49699303)
There is nothing I can do about that. Investors & shareholders believe that AI is the future so that's where all the money is going.
Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by vouaobrasil on Monday September 14, 2026 @01:37PM (#49700804)
I know. I just thought it was kind of a sad state of affairs....
Re:Unsolved Problem by Fields Medalist Breached by Two High ... by measurablefunc on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @12:04AM (#49707568)
I agree but that's the reality.