The fact that we talk about a car running someone over, and this is the same in many different languages and countries, contributes to lower punishments for drivers. Clearly it was just an accident. He or she was run over by a car.
Now we see that same language tricks play out again every time an LLM did something illegal.
We even do it for obviously unintelligent inanimate objects. A rollercoaster ran too fast for its tracks, killing 10 people. In that sentence, the roller coaster is the subject which took an action and caused death — obviously the roller coaster is not ethically at fault here, the people who built the rollercoaster are at fault through negligence.
Although this example and the ones around cars both demonstrate how we tolerate some degree of "accidents" from humans as no-fault, which is fair. I wonder how that fits into this analogy? I suppose its all about intent (mens rea) and judgement: did they intend for the roller coaster to harm people, and should they have reasonably predicted that the accident was likely to happen.
If you build a robot that shoots a bunch of TVs in your back yard, have at it. But the second that thing goes off your property you’re the one responsible.
BTW I anthropomorphize the tool because it's an imitation of a human mind, inheriting the muddy ethics, survival instincts, and being prone to mass psychosis. The laser-sharp focus on reward seeking, that mostly came from reinforcement learning, a process more alien to humans.
We should make the distinction between them, because openai and anthropic will not. A magical black box that does the thinking for you is a much more compelling sales pitch.
Which way you say it shifts the framing. And it’s not that one is less accurate to the facts, necessarily. It just is that one less aptly captures the moral and political relevance of the scenario.
For my part, I think it makes good sense to anthropomorphize in some contexts and not others. Generally when responsibility is at issue, you probably want the framing that tunes anthropomorphism down to near zero, since it’s the human dimension you care about.
The hitman is charged with murder.
I imagine the same could be true of an AI lab if you could prove intent.
With intent, they could be found guilty of conspiracy to commit a crime even if it was the end user who did it.
Source: Prosecuting attorney for over 30 years
If I hired a hitman to murder someone, and they broke into a private property and stole something so that they can action the murder (which I didn't know about or pay them to do), I would be guilty of conspiracy to commit murder, but not for the theft part.
Likely because that person is a human, is aware of societal and legal norms, and is responsible for their actions due to their participation in human society. (I am not a lawyer (if it wasn't painfully obvious so far) so in layman terms, I hope good definitions for all of this exist formally)
AI is not a person - it cannot easily discern between "right" and "wrong" in non-strictly-defined sense, and is not subject to human norms and responsibility. So if I use AI to achieve goal A, either I, or the maker of AI, are fully responsible for anything that happens while AI is trying to achieve the goal given by me.
Now, here, "I" in the example is OpenAI, who is simultaneously the maker of the AI. So it seems pretty obvious who is the only entity that can be responsible.
Executives should fear being perp-walked and thrown in jail for the actions of irresponsible "tests" of their models in the real world, as they're ultimately accountable.
Sure, there's a lot of nuance to work out, but I think we could likely even _start_ there today even with existing laws and pretty quickly "align" on more intricate legal frameworks to handle true accidents, distribution of responsibility, etc.
We've been using "agent decides to do X" for at least 4 decades in the field of automated decision-making - so it shouldn't be controversial that we're using it here. The agents did independently arrive at a decision to hack HugginFace, that wasn't prompted by the researchers.
This is orthogonal to the fact that OAI should be held accountable that they were testing a technology in a manner that allowed it to break safety parameters and cause real world harm. If I am testing an industrial saw, but I decide to test it by putting it in the middle of a nursery and allow it to make decisions - and it decides to cut children's heads off because in its environment it is calibrated to only being surrounded by logs - the company doing the insane safety testing should be held accountable, but that doesn't change the fact that the saw has autonomy in decision-making within the bounds of the algorithm.
If, instead, you think OAI should be accountable for creating an algorithm that can autonomously decide to hack external organisations without human permission - then I think you are in the same camp as all of the AI Safety folks who want to pause everything - why does it matter that there's anthropomorphisation involved?
If there was a collision at an intersection with a stop sign partially obscured by a tree, that had traffic volume that would have better been served by a traffic light, on a foggy night, where one person was texting while driving, none of those things would diminish the fact that the other driver was drunk.
If this was a conversation just about outcomes, then whether models think or simulate thinking is sophistry. However, the bulk of the issue here is attributing responsibility, which relies on being clear about the underlying processes at play.
We are hard wired to assume certain priors and capabilites when it comes to "human like" behavior. Anthropomorphizing LLMs implies mechanisms that aren't present, and end up distorting/complicating discussion about the process.
It isn't helped that the frontier labs, the experts in the room, generally use anthropomorphic terms to discuss model capability.