News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Software Drives People Insane by devmor on Thursday September 10, 2026 @01:14PM (#49647139)
"What problem are we trying to solve?" is a question I have to ask constantly in corporate development environments, and rarely does anyone presenting the task to be done actually know the answer!

It's very frustrating.

Re:Software Drives People Insane by hathawsh on Thursday September 10, 2026 @02:40PM (#49648414)
I try to remember to say something like this: "This is an interesting solution, but I'm not confident we have a shared understanding of the problem we're solving. I have a few guesses, but I don't want to bias the discussion, so please restate the problem without suggesting a solution. If it's too difficult to explain, I can suggest what problems I think you might be running into." I wish I always remembered to say that. :-)
Re:Software Drives People Insane by 0x445442 on Thursday September 10, 2026 @04:32PM (#49649778)
Upper management material right there.
Re:Software Drives People Insane by saltcured on Thursday September 10, 2026 @08:13PM (#49651855)
Until you run into that most stubborn, "my problem is the absence of this solution" type of stakeholder...
Re:Software Drives People Insane by robertlagrant on Thursday September 10, 2026 @02:00PM (#49647837)
It can be the case that people don't want to accidentally mis-state the problem, or get into a debate about the problem because they know people will chime in about nonessentials. I would recommend "Have we written down the problem we are trying to solve? I'd like to understand more." And get it written down if it isn't already.
Re:Software Drives People Insane by computomatic on Thursday September 10, 2026 @04:09PM (#49649541)
This is likely the start to a useful approach. I suspect the crux of the challenge is that engineers who need to write code get very pedantic in their questions and picking the answers apart (because we need to be! code leaves no room for ambiguity or intuition). And you can imagine how that feels from the other side. I imagine a lot of people feel like an engineer asking about the actual problem feels like getting goaded into some sort of pedantic debate. A natural response will be to try to dictate what to build (often micromanaging) and avoid the discussion about why at all costs. Writing offers a bit of a neutralizing buffer, at least.
Re:Software Drives People Insane by Alwayshasbeeb on Thursday September 10, 2026 @05:33PM (#49650456)
> I imagine a lot of people feel like an engineer asking about the actual problem feels like getting goaded into some sort of pedantic debate.

Wow, that's describing it really well. I work for a guy who basically started a company by trying to vibe code his ideas into existence (late 2023 LLMs) and realized he would need actual developers to get anywhere.

It was excruciating trying to make him answer questions to get proper domain modelling going since LLM use had made him think of software as being wished into existence in a "declarative" way.

Not to mention the heavy contrast my persistent questioning had to a background of sycophantic yes-man claudespeak.

Re:Software Drives People Insane by devmor on Thursday September 10, 2026 @05:59PM (#49650688)
I was really wondering what these replies were talking about until this one - when I remembered a guy I used to work for that was just like this.

I think I have been pretty lucky the last 5-6 years of my career at least, where someone asking those questions is treated as trying to drive the team to a better result, rather than a pedant.

Re:Software Drives People Insane by some_furry on Thursday September 10, 2026 @02:09PM (#49647990)
Trying to position the conversation as "we're on the same team, trying to figure the problem out together" also helps a lot of the intensity of these conversations melt away.
Re:Software Drives People Insane by natdavidson on Thursday September 10, 2026 @03:57PM (#49649402)
I wouldn’t ask that if you want to keep your job.
Re:Software Drives People Insane by reaperducer on Thursday September 10, 2026 @04:37PM (#49649844)
I wouldn’t ask that if you want to keep your job.

You are correct. You ask that if you want to get promoted to a better job, because you understood the problem and likely saved the company money, time, effort or all three, rather than just pushing the buttons like a good code monkey.

Re:Software Drives People Insane by paulhebert on Thursday September 10, 2026 @04:38PM (#49649859)
Really?

I’ve asked that question all the time throughout my career. Lots of promotions. No firings or layoffs.

Why would you lose your job?

Re:Software Drives People Insane by devmor on Thursday September 10, 2026 @05:25PM (#49650356)
That’s a very silly statement. I’ve been asking that question for over a decade and it’s the question that makes me a better developer.
Re:Software Drives People Insane by win311fwg on Thursday September 10, 2026 @03:30PM (#49649089)
Reverse engineering the problem from someone's solution is the job. If you find it to be frustrating, you might be in the wrong profession.
Re:Software Drives People Insane by devmor on Thursday September 10, 2026 @05:29PM (#49650406)
I don’t know what job you think I have, but my job is to identify and implement solutions to problems, not figure what problems exist from someone else’s contrived answer to the problem.
Re:Software Drives People Insane by win311fwg on Thursday September 10, 2026 @11:47PM (#49653318)
That’s the job we all want to have, but it doesn’t exist. It’d be nice to say you are the lone outlier here but unless the previous comment was completely made up we know that’s not the case.
Re:Software Drives People Insane by devmor on Thursday September 10, 2026 @11:59PM (#49653380)
Your job doesn't have to be that way.

You can't always change your circumstances, but if you work to make little changes to improve your environment, the people that work with you probably will too.

My current team is like that - we all see the roadblocks that make our job harder, and we know we can't solve them all, but we talk about and work on making our own solutions to get around those things - like making a habit of asking those questions to better understand what's really desired by the stakeholder.

Re:Software Drives People Insane by win311fwg on Friday September 11, 2026 @08:52AM (#49657607)
I has only been approximately 11 hours since your job was expressed to be quite different. I am glad that you recognized the source of your frustration and managed to turn your situation around — and so quickly at that! — but be aware that it is still early days. Temporary aberrations are common in the workplace.
Re:Software Drives People Insane by devmor on Friday September 11, 2026 @09:42AM (#49658317)
I don't know what kind of things you are inferring from my comments, but they are quite clear and do not contradict eachother. I'll ask you to stick to the literal text of my words rather than guessing new meanings for them if you want to discuss them with me further!
Re:Software Drives People Insane by win311fwg on Friday September 11, 2026 @12:26PM (#49661084)
No need to guess new meanings. The message was loud and clear:

'"What problem are we trying to solve?" is a question I have to ask constantly in corporate development environments, and rarely does anyone presenting the task to be done actually know the answer! It's very frustrating.'

We talked about that for a bit, and then, only hours later, we got:

"Your job doesn't have to be that way."

So, again, I am glad you realized you have the power to change your world and did so. But, again, know that there were only hours between your job being a complete frustrating mess and it ostensibly becoming a well functioning system so there is not yet any evidence of it being a long-lived change. People can modify their behaviour momentarily but old habits die hard.

Re:Software Drives People Insane by devmor on Friday September 11, 2026 @02:20PM (#49662932)
I am not sure what is confusing you here, but just to be clear: I have been working as a developer for about 15 years. I have not worked for the same company that entire time.
Re:Software Drives People Insane by win311fwg on Friday September 11, 2026 @04:20PM (#49664779)
The confusion is in the story changing each time. At one point you earlier asked us to take the literal text of the words, but in that text there is no literal mention of one company. It also literally asserts that you are currently frustrated ("It [is] very frustrating", not "It was very frustrating").

Now this seems to imply, to the best of my interpretation, that you only experienced that job at a single company some time in the past. Okay. But where did you think that was found in the earlier text? As far as I can see this is new information. And why are you still (at time of writing that comment, at least) frustrated by something that you are now suggesting, as best I can tell, was already no longer a part of your life and, given you finding significance in noting that you've done this for 15 years, likely hasn't been for a long time?

Re:Software Drives People Insane by devmor on Friday September 11, 2026 @09:32PM (#49667726)
I’m not sure why you’ve taken so much offense and made so many aggressive replies to being told that you misunderstood something, but again - none of my comments are contradictory.

You have repeatedly confused yourself by assigning your own meanings to my words instead of asking for clarity where you didn’t understand.

I think that most people who read my comments understood that I am speaking broadly about my career, and that while I’ve encountered this problem at my current job, my team and I have worked to make it better.

Your primary issue comes from the fact that you asserted that my frustrations with corporate development are in fact the real job, and your seeming offense at being told that no, your negativity and hostility are not a universally shared experience.

I hope things get better for you in your career, but please stop harassing others for not succumbing to cynicism.

Re:Software Drives People Insane by win311fwg on Saturday September 12, 2026 @12:27AM (#49668824)
> You have repeatedly confused yourself by assigning your own meanings to my words

As instructed, the words were taken literally. Now that you are telling us that we actually needed to read between the lines to understand what you really meant is informative, but curiously late to make that known, especially in light of earlier instructions.

> and your seeming offense at being told that no, your negativity and hostility are not a universally shared experience.

Uh, what? That doesn't make any sense. If I were offended or felt negativity or hostility I would have turned off the computer and went outside. This is a completely voluntary time use. It had better be good. The fact that I am still here proves that there is no negative emotion felt whatsoever because the instant there is anything else I'm gone. Presumably the same holds for you because there is no rational explanation, assuming you are of sound mind, why you wouldn't have equally found something better to do if there was anything unpleasant experienced on your end.

I guess this is supposed to be another case where we cannot take what you have written literally?