News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LibreOffice breaks download records after declaring it ha... by tempfile on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @11:41AM (#49611965)
I don't understand this comment. You don't seem to be disagreeing with OP?
Re:LibreOffice breaks download records after declaring it ha... by robrain on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @11:56AM (#49612181)
There is a specific record being claimed.

They're not just saying the absolute downloads are going up, as the OP suggests.

Re:LibreOffice breaks download records after declaring it ha... by tux3 on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @12:20PM (#49612498)
They're saying the weekly numbers grow a little bit every week, so every week is technically record breaking.

The absolute number of lifetime downloads can of course only go up (but that's even more vacuous).

Re:LibreOffice breaks download records after declaring it ha... by robrain on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @12:25PM (#49612563)
Their last sentence:

“Unix timestamp counter breaks record after writing this comment”

makes that vacuous connection, hence my original comment.

Re:LibreOffice breaks download records after declaring it ha... by ksymph on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @12:16PM (#49612453)
Their point was more that, if every 'weekly download count after a new release' (or whatever record) is consistently being broken on each new release due to generally increasing popularity, then it doesn't make sense to imply causality between the messaging around this particular release and its already-expected record-breaking status.
Re:LibreOffice breaks download records after declaring it ha... by Timon3 on Tuesday September 08, 2026 @12:44PM (#49612821)
And that's the case? Weekly download numbers have been consistently trending upwards?
Re:LibreOffice breaks download records after declaring it ha... by tempfile on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @04:18AM (#49623115)
But that is perfectly consistent with the downloads incrementally going up all the time. It doesn't say anything about whether the recent policy changes increased that rate.
Re:LibreOffice breaks download records after declaring it ha... by Timon3 on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @04:41AM (#49623279)
I'm sure you've actually checked the download numbers and are not just going "well akshually", right?
Re:LibreOffice breaks download records after declaring it ha... by tempfile on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @05:28AM (#49623681)
Excuse you? What I originally said was "I don't understand your comment". They posted a clarification, and the clarification still doesn't make sense. No, I haven't read the download numbers. How is that going "well akshually"?
Re:LibreOffice breaks download records after declaring it ha... by Timon3 on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @05:38AM (#49623743)
The clarification makes sense, unless you presuppose that download numbers are consistently trending upwards.
Re:LibreOffice breaks download records after declaring it ha... by tempfile on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @06:06AM (#49623990)
No, it doesn't. If the claim is just that download numbers are not consistently trending upwards, they should have just said that. I would have no trouble understanding that. What they actually said is "Libreoffice didn't say the numbers were going up, they claimed a specific record." Well, so what? Nobody said Libreoffice said that! The OP said that, because if it's true, then it's not surprising that the latest stat (release or not) is the highest ever. Nobody in the thread so far has said anything that contradicts "the numbers were going up anyway, therefore the record might not be to do with the AI policy".

The numbers graph is spiky and I can imagine you could argue either way that they are generally trending up or not. But that's irrelevant!

Re:LibreOffice breaks download records after declaring it ha... by Timon3 on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @06:40AM (#49624276)
This objection is completely meaningless unless the download numbers follow a consistent upwards trend. You are simplifying the new record to a boolean, but most people still find meaning in extraordinary events happening, even if they follow a general trend.

So I fail to see this discussion as anything but sophistry until anyone demonstrates that the download numbers are totally ordinary. It's typical HN contrarianism without any value, because it's enough to argue for the possibility of something, even when the data for checking it is easily accessible.

Re:LibreOffice breaks download records after declaring it ha... by Ukv on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @07:05AM (#49624492)
I think the confusion is that robrain somehow understood smokel's objection as being "all-time total downloads obviously increase over time, so this is meaningless", rather than what smokel actually said which was "the number of weekly downloads has simply been increasing over time". Which is why robrain quoted LibreOffice's "This is the highest number of downloads in the first week”, to counter the idea (which nobody suggested) that the record was just about all-time cumulative downloads going up.

That's then what tempfile was questioning how it contradicted smokel's claim (because it doesn't, just an imagined claim). Your points, that if the number of weekly downloads isn't actually consistently increasing then this could still be meaningful, are valid - but irrelevant to tempfile who was wasn't arguing that this is meaningless; you should argue that to smokel instead.