News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First Sale Under Siege: If You Bought It, You Should Own It by AnthonyMouse on Sunday December 23, 2012 @05:29PM (#4960934)
>I understood it to be ruling that disallows you from buying abroad and importing. So if they moved production to Mexico, but then they imported and sold it to you, it would not matter - you'd still have first sale.

The key word in that sentence is "they" -- who is "they"?

Here's the problem: The copyright holder manufactures the product abroad and sells it abroad to a nominally unaffiliated distributor who then imports it into the United States. In theory the distributor is doing what would not be allowed -- importing the foreign product without a license -- but the copyright holder gets to decide whether or not to sue them. And they don't sue them, this one unofficial distributor with whom they have an unspoken agreement. They only sue you when you go to resell the used product, claiming it was never sold by the copyright holder in the United States.

Maybe you could make some claim that the distributor had a de facto license based on the fact that the copyright holder implicitly allowed the importing to continue, but good luck proving it when they claim it was unsanctioned (and meanwhile they have a token official U.S. reseller with near-zero sales volume who sells at 5X the price, and a list of other unsanctioned importers who they've sued to shut down).

There are no comments on this comment yet.