Re:First Sale Under Siege: If You Bought It, You Should Own It
by belorn on Sunday December 23, 2012 @04:48PM
(#4960801)
Given the practice of tax dodging, how many items are really sold in the US by US webstores? Are you sure that all those amazon books are sold "in the US" and not from Ireland or some small island somewhere?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:First Sale Under Siege: If You Bought It, You Should Own It
by anigbrowl on Sunday December 23, 2012 @06:04PM
(#4961046)
If the transaction is initiated by a US consumer inside the US, it's considered to be a US sale. If you dig into the case law on this, you'll find that the concept of first sale doctrine is perfectly well understood by the legal establishment and is not about to shrivel up and blow away.
There's an excellent (albeit technical) introduction to these issues in the 9th circuit's ruling on Omega S.A. v. Costco Wholesale Corp.. Read up also on some of the journal articles from the Wiki page: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omega_S.A._v._Costco_Wholesale_.... and if you're really itnerested, dig into the amicus briefs.
Re:First Sale Under Siege: If You Bought It, You Should Own It
by schoen on Sunday December 23, 2012 @09:20PM
(#4961563)
The Second Circuit specifically disagreed with the Ninth Circuit on this point, distinguishing its holding from the Ninth Circuit's in Omega.
Re:First Sale Under Siege: If You Bought It, You Should Own It
by rmc on Sunday December 23, 2012 @05:19PM
(#4960900)
As someone from Ireland, I'll tell you amazon, despite having s large EU office here and their AWS European region here, do not actually sell much here. There is no amazon.ie, you must buy from the UK amazon.co.uk or the US amazon.com. If you have a kindle, you must use the US amazon.com kindle store. If you have a customer service complaint about your kindle you have to eventually find a US customer service number.
Not to negate your general point though.
Re:First Sale Under Siege: If You Bought It, You Should Own It
by justincormack on Sunday December 23, 2012 @05:29PM
(#4960938)
In the US they are still sold onshore at present. Although the state they are sold from is an issue. This could change though of course.