If we learned one thing from the music industry over the last 15 years, it's that the internet gives your customers the power to destroy you if you treat them with contempt for long enough.
I love to read and I happily buy many Kindle books at $9.99+ a pop on Amazon. I want to live in a world where authors can make a living by writing. But bogus restrictions on book sharing, complete lack of a resale market, etc. are already starting to rub me the wrong way. At some point, if pushed too far, I'm not going to feel much remorse about flouting the system.
Couldn't agree more with this sentiment.
Is this your legal opinion as a lawyer?
After all, the difference between leasing and buying is exactly right to use vs ownership.
Leasing/licensing have retention of ownership in the provider, buying does not.
Without having thought about it for more than 5 minutes, I can't think of any legal difference other than terminology.
Note that there is a difference in real property: Licensing is about giving someone the right to do something that would otherwise be unlawful, whereas leasing is generally about right to possess.
However, this is not the distinction software "licenses" are making.
I will admit that "legally speaking" was perhaps not accurate. But is it really?
If i cannot leave something to my son in my will, it was never mine to begin with. You can't inherit kindle books, so it's obvious that you don't buy them either. There's no such thing as "buying a license", legally speaking that's called "renting".