Re:GNU sed 4.2.2 released, maintainer resigns
by kroger on Sunday December 23, 2012 @09:24PM
(#4961577)
Both GNU sed and BSD sed have -i, what other kinds of sed are you using?
Re:GNU sed 4.2.2 released, maintainer resigns
by wzm on Monday December 24, 2012 @08:31PM
(#4964738)
/usr/bin/sed on Solaris 10 and earlier does not support -i. I don't know if OpenIndiana / Solaris 11's sed support -i, but OmniOS uses gnu sed by default, so OI might also.
As I recall, AIX's default sed also does not support -i, but I no longer have access to AIX systems to test against.
If I really want to create temp files I can use ed or use sed with shell redirection. Were it for some reason a requirement, I can avoid temp files, at least for the substitution (s) command, as follows:
This is not "perfect" as there will blank lines, but it does the job without temp files (if that were really a concern).If GNU grep was in need of repair and you fixed it, then I thank you. But I'm not clear on how that justifies any "extensions" to GNU grep.
Maintenance, at least to me, means fixing things, not extending them and adding more complexity and things that can potentially break or create incompatibilities across different UNIX's.