News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hamming: "dubious that great programmers can be trained.." by jt2190 on Sunday December 23, 2012 @12:26PM (#4959975)
Hemming's point can be summed up with this pithy question:

Do you have n years of experience, or n * 1 year of experience?

Spending years on the job learning nothing or barely learning lots of programming languages does not make one into a great programmer.

My mother taught creative writing, and it's exactly the same. Writers got good ultimately by writing, not by reading books about writing or taking classes on writing.

(edit: Let me add that this is a central problem faced by educators: The good ones know that they can't teach/train success directly, rather that the students must take that training and educate themselves about how to use it to achieve their own success.)

Re:Hamming: "dubious that great programmers can be trained.." by summerdown2 on Sunday December 23, 2012 @05:43PM (#4960979)
> Writers got good ultimately by writing, not by reading books about writing or taking classes on writing.

I'm not sure this is true. I've had a little success in short story writing, and have been pushing myself to get better over quite a few years now. At least for me, writing seems necessary but not sufficient. I have to:

    * Write

    * Think hard about what I write

    * Critique other writers

    * Read books by people who know the subject

    * Write some more
The key seems to be reflecting as well as writing. It's essentially a constant struggle to improve rather than just cranking the handle. I think that's why the answer to:

> Do bureaucrats after years of writing reports and instructions get better?

is no. They're not striving to be better.