News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Blue-collar knowledge workers will save the economy by tibbon on Saturday December 22, 2012 @08:21PM (#4958162)
I've tried to get a few friends into development who aren't developers. These are people working at $8-10/hr, often upward of 50 hours a week. Even moving up to $25/hr would be a massive life change for them, and given hiring trends in tech I thought it would be a great move for them, even if they weren't great at it for a few years.

Its been a miserable failure. I've come to the conclusion that programming is hard, and I've been incredibly privileged by having a computer since I was 2 (C64!) and I have so much built in knowledge that I don't even realize I have.

Also, this stuff just isn't fun for a lot of people. Sometimes its downright painful for them and they just can't push themselves through the tough parts motivation-wise. I can imagine it being a bit like doing Crossfit (or any exercise). I know I'd be a lot healthier if I did it for a year. But the upfront expense, the pain, and being incredibly bad at it for the first few months just makes it so I don't even try- even though I know the benefits could be life changing.

I bought a copy of Agile Development on Rails and gave it to such a friend. He didn't know how to pull up a command prompt, and I realized that he didn't know what a text editor was. Or that you'd run things from the terminal, and type them in the text editor. I helped him get past that, but he never focused in on it and never saw the beautiful and amazing parts of it.

Another friend got a little farther. But I soon realized how much 'background' knowledge he was missing. I pointed him toward some free online CS courses, which helped. But life got in the way and it just wasn't the #1 thing for him, so he got distracted and quit when he moved to a new (small) city.

Another friend wanted help getting started. He was motivated, but we hit a major problem. He's a student with an older iBook. We had huge issues setting up Ruby due to various environmental problems. I didn't have the time to really redo his entire system, but I wasn't able to get Ruby installed easily since he was on 10.3 or something ancient.

Just telling people that there are boatloads of money to be had, and that there are tons of resources out there doesn't always work. They really have to love it to get through that first painful year or so.

Now perhaps having more jobs (these knowledge factories) that will give people an environment to work in, the tools, the training, etc... might help. But otherwise, I've just seen that I have personally been a complete and utter failure at helping friends get into programming. I'm thankful that I have a background that makes it easy for me to do and learn, but many just don't have that background and I don't know how to help them get past that.

Re:Blue-collar knowledge workers will save the economy by zampano on Sunday December 23, 2012 @12:03AM (#4958657)
Anecdotally, I went from working a part-time job making 11/hour a year ago to working full-time as a (very) junior Rails developer for double my old pay after a friend encouraged me to make the transition. I did have a lot of general computing experience from being a computer gaming nerd as a kid and in high school, but I had always stopped short of coding after a few abortive forays when I was in my early teens (though I did have some knowledge of late 1990s HTML and CSS).

I too had issues with hardware (my only computer was a $300 netbook) but I got around this by getting a Linode and using that to do all my development. This had the added benefit of forcing me to familiarize myself with the command line and Vim/tmux (though, I do admit I had some experience with basic commands from trying out linux a few times when I had been younger and too broke for Windows).

In my case, I was so hopelessly in debt and so upset with the aimless path my life had been taking that I threw myself into programming. It was extremely difficult at first since there were a ton of concepts that I had to learn even to be able to understand the official documentation. I found myself going through beginner tutorials and books over and over, each time picking up more details and each time coming away with more understanding. When I had trouble figuring out Rails, I went deeper and tried to understand Ruby first. When I felt I wasn't making any progress (it took me months to really wrap my head around blocks until one day it just dawned on me), I would explore Javascript or try to update my html/css knowledge to modern standards or explore the wonderful world of man pages. I even made an effort to make any procrastination beneficial by making sure it was "on-topic" by reading Hacker News, toying with project euler or studying math. In short, I tried to make thinking like a programmer my life. I felt like I had a lot of catching up to do with those who had been programming from their youth. I also wasn't sure if the current booming market would perpetuate forever and I didn't want to miss my chance to gain precious experience while the door was still open to me.

This was probably the first time in my life I had devoted myself so fully to anything. I had always been someone with one thousand differing interests and lacked in-depth knowledge in many subjects. It was hard giving up things like photography and probably-excessive reading (I would often spend entire weekends reading through piles of books) to focus on something that was often not as relaxing or easy, but I found the challenge incredibly stimulating (more stimulating than anything I had encountered in university for instance) and it wasn't long until I found my mind constantly wandering toward whatever concept I had been learning or working on.

While I originally was enticed by the financial benefit of programming, I find that to not be a large factor in why I work today. Once I got out of my financial hole, it was like being able to breath for the first time and in an instant I stopped caring about pushing my way to the top. The thing that gets me up in the morning now is the thrill of solving the problem and that wonderful feeling of accomplishment when you realize that what you worked on is succinct, beautiful and works. I have been trying to encourage some of my friends who are now stuck in dead-end low-paying jobs, surviving thanks to credit cards and on the verge of devastation by something as minor as needing new tires for their car, but I have yet to have any success in pushing anyone in this direction. Like you, anyone I've tried to encourage has usually fallen off the wagon pretty quickly. Maybe it was simply easier for me since I was never scared to tinker or play with the computer. Maybe I'm just a bit more obsessive.

Whatever the reason, I couldn't be happier where I am today. I get to build things and solve problems/troubleshoot everyday. I get to work with smart people who genuinely work hard at what they do. I look forward to expanding my knowledge and improving myself and my code for the foreseeable future and maybe, one day, building my own business and my own product to help change the world like so many of you guys have.

So, I know it can be discouraging when your friends don't stick with programming, but don't write off everybody because of a handful. Even if it is rare, there are a few of us out there who just need the right kind of push. As the old saying goes, "you can lead a horse to water, but you can't make them drink".

Re:Blue-collar knowledge workers will save the economy by needles1986 on Monday December 24, 2012 @10:23AM (#4963037)
As I was reading your comment I couldn't stop vigorously nodding my head in agreement at nearly everything you said, especially the part about it being hard giving up photography and excessive reading in order to pursue programming. I feel like I'm exactly at the point you were when you began you journey into programming. Thanks for leaving this comment!
Re:Blue-collar knowledge workers will save the economy by seldo on Saturday December 22, 2012 @11:51PM (#4958616)
You are absolutely right, and that's the point of my post. Programming is too hard. We can't make all these people become programmers. But a lot of what we are doing as programmers shouldn't really require programming.

When I'm building a website for a small business, I'm not breaking any new technical ground. They need an inventory database, product news, search, an ordering and fulfillment system. At the moment, there are a bunch of systems that promise to fill that niche, but they usually still need somebody who knows HTML and CSS if they're going to customize them to any degree. Why is that? There should be WYSIWYG editors for these things. You should be able to drag-and-drop drupal modules into place in an editor, not glue them together with configs and code.

Your friend shouldn't have to know about Ruby or Rails or Agile development. The fundamentals of computer science are as relevant to building a low-traffic website as the fundamentals of chemistry are to baking a cake. Sure, you do better if you know them, but 99% of people can get by just fine by trial and error.

What the people who have CS degrees should be doing is not building websites; they should be building the WYSIWYG editors.

Re:Blue-collar knowledge workers will save the economy by raffi on Sunday December 23, 2012 @12:14AM (#4958687)
So what you're suggesting is we should teach these people how to administer WordPress sites?
Re:Blue-collar knowledge workers will save the economy by seldo on Sunday December 23, 2012 @12:17AM (#4958701)
Close, but not quite. Think of something only a little more complicated to configure than Wordpress, but far more powerful -- something that actually generates sales and provides immediate value. Software that does for other industries what Wordpress did for publishing -- one for each industry. Wordpress for restaurants, Wordpress for dentists, Wordpress for auto mechanics. And not just a website, but a full web-based system that replaces whatever crappy CRM system they're using. Software that fixes their problems, not just software that gives them a domain name.

I don't want the dentist and the mechanic to be configuring this software -- that's what I want the "blue collar programmer" to be doing, after a few weeks of training. But I want the dentist and the mechanic to use the software after it's configured.

(Also, to do much useful in Wordpress, you soon need to learn CSS and HTML, if not PHP. That's still too complicated. I want these tools to require no coding at all.)

Re:Blue-collar knowledge workers will save the economy by AnthonyMouse on Sunday December 23, 2012 @01:14AM (#4958794)
I don't think the end result of those sorts of tools is going to go where you want it to go.

The trouble is that if it's sufficiently easy and painless that the "blue collar programmer" can do it in three hours, the guy who owns the auto shop or the restaurant who wants the website can probably figure out how to do it in twice that long and is liable to choose that over paying someone money.

Or, the smart people who are doing it today will then be able to use the new tools plus a trivial amount of code to do it in fifteen minutes instead of three hours, which won't create any new jobs, it will just make simple websites much cheaper because they can be "mass produced" by a subset of the same people who are making them now.

If you want to attack the problem of unskilled workers without somehow converting them into skilled workers, try going at it from the other end: Find ways to reduce the cost of living for those people (i.e. reduce the cost of food, housing and medical care). That better allows those people to make a living on the low wages incident to their skill level.

People always ignore that aspect of standard of living because the incentives to fix it are counter-intuitive or have strong lobbies against them. The way you make things less expensive is by reducing margins (and thus profits -- and thus tax revenue) or by increasing automation and eliminating even more unskilled jobs. But the net effect is to increase prospects for the average unskilled worker, because those with existing jobs in effect have more money in their pockets, and those with no jobs can now accept a lower paying job while achieving the same standard of living.

Re:Blue-collar knowledge workers will save the economy by AdrianRossouw on Sunday December 23, 2012 @02:39AM (#4958907)
It already exists, and it's called Drupal. It's entire goal/purpose is to allow you to do everything through the user interface. There is a very large group of 'Drupal Developers' who build entire sites solely through the admin interface. It also has different install profiles/distributions for pre-built niches.

I used to be want the same things as you do, but it has taken me many many years to internalize the lesson that somewhere, somehow, you WILL need to write code to reach your goals. The more you try to dodge and dive around that core truth of all software, the harder the code that you will need to write ends up becoming.

Re:Blue-collar knowledge workers will save the economy by rizzom5000 on Sunday December 23, 2012 @12:27AM (#4958727)
It sounds like what you're describing is something like a cross between a pipe dream and what already exists.

Wordpress already exists and there are many folks, and many or most without CS degrees, who will happily develop and administer a site for you. The pipe dream comes in when you expect those sites to generate sales and provide immediate value. If every dentist in my community uses your magical Wordpress site, will sales and value magically increase for all of them?

Re:Blue-collar knowledge workers will save the economy by spinchange on Sunday December 23, 2012 @12:47AM (#4958746)
You still need to know at least a little PHP/HTML/CSS if you want to do any substantive customization.
Re:Blue-collar knowledge workers will save the economy by tsotha on Saturday December 22, 2012 @08:36PM (#4958206)
Programming is one of those things some people just don't have the knack for, and no matter how long they stay with it and how hard they try they'll never be more than barely productive. The industry is already full of those kinds of people shuffling from one three month contracting gig to another.

We're not going to retrain blue collar workers to do IT as it's done now, and the factory model doesn't work - consulting companies have been trying to do this for decades with no success (well, aside from billing a whole lot of hours).

If we want to deal with high unemployment on the lower rungs of the job ladder we need to stop the flood of illegal immigrants. Any small gains we try to make by bringing people up the ladder will be washed away in short order.

Re:Blue-collar knowledge workers will save the economy by dizzystar on Saturday December 22, 2012 @08:53PM (#4958253)
The other element missing from the post you responded to is that self-learning is very effing hard. I would say that fewer than 1/50 people can teach themselves anything of value to the job market.

I also have to point out that, as an ex-blue-collar worker myself, that blue-collar workers in generally really don't care about education or any intellectual pursuits. Sorry, but the glove of doing programming doesn't fit everyone, and it shouldn't fit everyone. The world is interesting because we all have our unique abilities.

Re:Blue-collar knowledge workers will save the economy by jfarmer on Saturday December 22, 2012 @08:47PM (#4958235)
I think this is easy to say, but hard to prove. It's certainly the conventional wisdom among software engineers.
Re:Blue-collar knowledge workers will save the economy by tsotha on Sunday December 23, 2012 @02:11AM (#4958864)
It's an observation. I'm not sure what other proof I need.
Re:Blue-collar knowledge workers will save the economy by Retric on Saturday December 22, 2012 @09:36PM (#4958360)
I work for a fairly large 20,000+ mostly non IT consulting firm that has a solid reputation for getting things done. Most programmers make on the lower end of ~60-110k and code quality tends to sit just above terrible. However, what works for us is simply focusing on solving problems not meeting specks which is the antithesis of the factory model.

Granted, if they knew who to higher and what problems they needed to solve they would get by at 1/3 of our what we charge. But, most people and organisations are unbelievably incompetent.

PS: As to immigration a lot of the work done by immigrants would simply disappear without immigrant labor because it's just not worth minimum wage and or could just as easily be done outside the country. However, when it comes to the upper ends of the work force we are far better off with them than without. Don't forget Sergey Brin was born in Russia and I don't think we would be better off without Google.

Re:Blue-collar knowledge workers will save the economy by tsotha on Sunday December 23, 2012 @02:07AM (#4958858)
>As to immigration a lot of the work done by immigrants would simply disappear without immigrant labor because it's just not worth minimum wage and or could just as easily be done outside the country.

But a lot more of it would still need to be done, and people would get paid enough that going off public assistance made sense.

Also, don't conflate illegal immigrants with legal immigrants. Sergey Brin didn't slip over the border with a sixth grade education and no ability to speak English. What we lack is jobs for people on the left half of the bell curve. There's plenty of room on the right half.

Re:Blue-collar knowledge workers will save the economy by togasystems on Saturday December 22, 2012 @10:16PM (#4958424)
I have a friend who is a ticketed carpenter. He found the construction industry boring, corrupt and decided to change careers into computers. My first training session went well, but there was only so much I could teach him in the time alotted.

We both came to the realization that he needed formal edication for both learning the concepts and gaining credibility. He just finished his first semester and is loving it!

Instead of being the teacher, point your friends to people that are trained to educate. If the person is serious about changing their life, school is the first place they should go.

Re:Blue-collar knowledge workers will save the economy by jebblue on Saturday December 22, 2012 @11:04PM (#4958536)
>> Instead of being the teacher, point your friends to people that are trained to educate. If the person is serious about changing their life, school is the first place they should go.

I'm a terrible teacher for others but I teach myself amazingly well. Reasoning that if you're not a good teacher then the only alternative is a formal school; I'd say there are more options such as self-teaching. It doesn't work for as many people but does work very well for some.