News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Placebo Phenomenon by revelation on Saturday December 22, 2012 @04:36PM (#4957552)
I get very uneasy reading articles that start to pitch "value of caring" and someone who "didn't doubt the value of acupuncture" against "western medicine" and "western doctors" who are portrayed as stubborn and close-minded.
Re:The Placebo Phenomenon by thirdtruck on Saturday December 22, 2012 @05:40PM (#4957733)
Agreed. "Western medicine" only exists as half of a false dichotomy.

If the doctors so labeled really were stubborn and close-minded, then we would still perform blood-lettings and chew tree mark (instead of just the active ingredient). Instead, these doctors are more open to new information; they're just willing to also incorporate the evidence against efficacy so often ignored by "alternative medicine" practitioners.

Re:The Placebo Phenomenon by wisty on Saturday December 22, 2012 @11:48PM (#4958613)
That's not 100% true. It's only really the case in patent protected medicines.

New drugs undergo testing, to get FDA approval. New surgical treatments don't. New (and old) surgical treatments and old drugs aren't lucrative enough to warrant real testing. Surgeons will claim it's for ethical reasons, or because they just know better, or that they are artists who can't be constrained by the laws of statistics, but it's simply a lack of regulations and / or incentives.

Re:The Placebo Phenomenon by thirdtruck on Sunday December 23, 2012 @11:10AM (#4959754)
That's not 100% true.

Correct. That's why I expressed it as a relative position instead of making any such absolute claims.