News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Merry Doomsday HN: All of my YC Facelifts are free to dow... by ErrantX on Saturday December 22, 2012 @08:32AM (#4956521)
His redesigns are very clearly significantly better

So some extent, yes this is true.

However he is a designer and not a marketer, this is clear. For example; Exec has a brilliant and clear marketing message, which gets completely lost in the redesign.

Many of the other designs suffer the same lack of consideration in terms of how to communicate a brand.

Not that I think this is a bad thing to do! It's all practice and good fun.

I'm just noting that, objectively, these designs are far from perfect and the originals often have other things going for them compared to looks nice/easy to use.

Re:Merry Doomsday HN: All of my YC Facelifts are free to dow... by jenius on Tuesday December 25, 2012 @01:28PM (#4966634)
That could certainly be true, and is a good point. I was only speaking to the visual design here - message is definitely important though.