News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stop Conflating Violence and Mental Illness by nerdfiles on Saturday December 22, 2012 @06:58AM (#4956411)
I wasn't going to respond to this article, or even read it, or even really acknowledge the HN culture anymore on account of gems like this, but in all honesty: SRSLY?

___Autism is mostly boy's disorder. That picture is about clinical depression, which is women's trait, and it is just being shut in oneself.___

The loaded _gender-nomenclature_ of this patriarchal, advanced-capitalist polyarchy has become so freaking thick that I would find it laughable if scientific literature (STEMers) even distills 5% of it from shared knowledge 100 years from now.

___In a similar vein, Baron-Cohen and Hammer (1997) argued that, whereas individuals with autism have extreme “male brains,” with better spatial skills than social skills, those with Williams syndrome show the reverse pattern and, as such, may be characterized as having extreme “female brains.” ___ -- https://sites.google.com/site/drjonbrock/publications/the-ot...

Now looking at your statement, we have terms like "boy's disorder" contrasted with "women's trait".

What are you talking about? With Williams Syndrome we have "female brains" so with every reason to believe that they are alone in clinical depression. That is, by your grammar of reasoning. But what is more?:

___This view of Williams syndrome and autism as diametric opposites has, however, proven to be somewhat simplistic (Tager-Flusberg, Plesa-Skwerer, & Joseph, 2006). Despite their sociable and empathetic personalities, individuals with Williams syndrome are often reported as having high levels of social anxiety (Dykens, 2003; Udwin, Yule, & Martin, 1987). Children with Williams syndrome typically prefer adult company to mixing with their own age group, and have great diffi culty making and sustaining friendships (Einfeld, Tonge, & Florio, 1997; Rosner, Hodapp, Fidler, Sagun, & Dykens, 2004; Udwin et al., 1987). The two disorders also overlap clinically.___ -- https://sites.google.com/site/drjonbrock/publications/the-ot...

So what are you, in factual terms, please, sir, saying? What is going on here, where your post ranks highest, and you have express'd what seems to be unessential and obfuscating sexist language, in such a way as to talk about what is clinical; and current research says, quite simply, and quite exactly the opposite of what you theorize on with false knowledge; if indeed they clinically overlap, that is?

Re:Stop Conflating Violence and Mental Illness by dschiptsov on Saturday December 22, 2012 @08:46AM (#4956540)
It is not me, it is plain dumb statistics. Wast majority of cases of ASDs are reported in a male population, while clinical depression in female.

Baron-Cohen's argument sounds solid if you consider that women evolve non-verbal communication skill they use with babies, who cannot talk until of age of 2. All that communication is well-researched and documented. Autistic people have difficulties in communication, and no wonder that they are mostly men.

As of language usage, different cultures, well, tend to use a language differently. Most of world's cultures, by the way, does not believe in an gender equality and tend to name things, as we believe, they are. There are differences between men and women and they aren't just anatomical.)

Re:Stop Conflating Violence and Mental Illness by nerdfiles on Saturday December 22, 2012 @04:43PM (#4957577)
Re:Stop Conflating Violence and Mental Illness by drequivalent on Saturday December 22, 2012 @07:15AM (#4956425)
With all the respect to gender equality supporters (to which I count myself), why so much butthurt?
Re:Stop Conflating Violence and Mental Illness by nerdfiles on Saturday December 22, 2012 @07:24AM (#4956437)
What does this have to do with gender equality? I'm talking about his "theorizing" and his "nomenclature". I am talking about his method and his "grammar." I am talking about the future state of existing true statements that may exist in our scientific literature in "the next 100 years." I am dealing with Popperian-style skepticism; this is philosophy of science. Please, understand. I want sense, from nonsense. That is a big issue to me, essentially since I just read his post with http://antijingoist.github.com/AlphaSymbolic/. And quite frankly, I'm not happy about it. All I see is a logical paradox. A sequence of linguistic markers, and his paradoxical blobs of AlphaSymbolic text is way to clear to me. It's way too eerily clear.

Please see http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/logic-paraconsistent/.

This human man is clearly using language in a way that is expected and fits along a normalized pattern that suggests "rational." However, his theorizing immediately leads to "explosion"; so it is a matter, then, of what content quantities of his exist which, in principle, say nothing. How much of any of this paradoxical language exists? And how did we get to a point in society where what he says passes off as passively authoritative? -- What are we filling the Internet with? -- Ultimately, when I reflect on Godel's proof, Candor's diagonalization, it all becomes too clear that our Western society is intolerant to difference; and this can undermine scientific progress.

I am concern'd with consistency and the stress of things like general internet ecologies (and hypermedia applications) on organic cognitive systems (like us). Because, quite simply, What is going on here? What is he talking about? Is it informational? Operational? Pragmatic? Dogmatic?

What does his content and its ilk engender in terms of rational, dialectical discussion with no obvious linguistic glitches that mislead and misinform.

Re:Stop Conflating Violence and Mental Illness by nerdfiles on Saturday December 22, 2012 @07:39AM (#4956458)
And really, you nerds write like robots all day. I have to put up with that, and I cannot use expressive language?

You address none of my claims; the response I get is "butthurt."

What is this? That is what I am asking. Right now. This conversation; starting from "boy's disorder"; and then "butthurt" -- what is that? It's a mod-chic-Nietzschean way of saying "womanish." Did I fail to generate a proposition such that your internal theory of mind, or inner homunculus, do not perceive it?

[Edit:] Fascinating. 1 hour, 5 downvotes and a response later, still none the wiser. I even gave away a futuristic subplot for it. Low point.