Re:Forbidden planet: was Pluto's 2006 demotion a big mistake?
by odyssey7 on Monday August 31, 2026 @08:14PM
(#49516412)
Unfortunately this is both a false dichotomy fallacy and an appeal to extremes.
1. Yes, there are culturally significant things that have happened since the 1930s, including the discovery of Pluto and its designation as being a planet. In fact, in 2006, a group of people got together -- known as the IAU -- and they also performed a cultural act amongst themselves when they decided to stop calling Pluto a planet, undertaking a social process in adopting criteria for doing so.
2. If you would rather define a planet is a wandering star that's visible to unaided humans in the night sky, I'd respect that, and I kind of like the idea. It avoids the myriad issues that the article here discusses. The problem comes up when you police what other people call things, not when you decide to subscribe to the IAU of your own volition.
1. Yes, there are culturally significant things that have happened since the 1930s, including the discovery of Pluto and its designation as being a planet. In fact, in 2006, a group of people got together -- known as the IAU -- and they also performed a cultural act amongst themselves when they decided to stop calling Pluto a planet, undertaking a social process in adopting criteria for doing so.
2. If you would rather define a planet is a wandering star that's visible to unaided humans in the night sky, I'd respect that, and I kind of like the idea. It avoids the myriad issues that the article here discusses. The problem comes up when you police what other people call things, not when you decide to subscribe to the IAU of your own volition.