Re:Nate Silver confuses cause and effect, ends up defending ...
by Symmetry on Thursday December 20, 2012 @03:57PM
(#4949936)
What, specifically, isn't true?
An argument doesn't have to contain a false statement to have no baring on the discussion.
And more generally it's quite possible for a thing to have multiple causes, and in this universe this is generally true for everything we witness. So if A causes C that doesn't mean that B can't also cause C "by definition". I'm not aware of any serious philosphical framework that says that events must have only a single cause, though many philosophers from Aristotle onwards[1] but great stock in the "final cause" of things, but that would be either "God" or "The Big Bang" depending on your religion or lack thereof and nobody was arguing for those.
And as an aside, the words "by definition" in an argument that isn't on it's surface about definitions is generally a bit of a red flag.[2]
An argument doesn't have to contain a false statement to have no baring on the discussion.
And more generally it's quite possible for a thing to have multiple causes, and in this universe this is generally true for everything we witness. So if A causes C that doesn't mean that B can't also cause C "by definition". I'm not aware of any serious philosphical framework that says that events must have only a single cause, though many philosophers from Aristotle onwards[1] but great stock in the "final cause" of things, but that would be either "God" or "The Big Bang" depending on your religion or lack thereof and nobody was arguing for those.
And as an aside, the words "by definition" in an argument that isn't on it's surface about definitions is generally a bit of a red flag.[2]
[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teleology [2]http://lesswrong.com/lw/nz/arguing_by_definition/