Re:Nate Silver confuses cause and effect, ends up defending ...
by pdonis on Thursday December 20, 2012 @03:00PM
(#4949606)
Silver isn't just claming that A<-B. He is claiming that fixing B will fix A, and that fixing B is straightforward: just use good models.
mathbabe is saying that fixing B is not straightforward, because B<-C, and fixing C is very, very difficult. Bad models exist because people have incentives to make them bad.
She's also saying, I think, that fixing B by itself won't fix A, because B is not the root cause; C is. Fixing B without fixing C just means that C will manifest itself somewhere else, and A will still happen. In other words, there are many causal routes from C to A, and fixing B by itself only blocks one of them. So A<-C is true regardless of the state of B.
mathbabe is saying that fixing B is not straightforward, because B<-C, and fixing C is very, very difficult. Bad models exist because people have incentives to make them bad.
She's also saying, I think, that fixing B by itself won't fix A, because B is not the root cause; C is. Fixing B without fixing C just means that C will manifest itself somewhere else, and A will still happen. In other words, there are many causal routes from C to A, and fixing B by itself only blocks one of them. So A<-C is true regardless of the state of B.