Re:EFF Patent Project Gets Half-Million-Dollar Boost from Ma...
by krichman on Thursday December 20, 2012 @02:29AM
(#4946669)
> The usual way to address this is to add additional, easy to prove thresholds that let a case be dismissed without consideration of involved questions.
This, absolutely. Giving defendants an inexpensive way to challenge patents which should not have been issued and get the case dropped would basically end this nonsense as soon at it was enacted.
As it is now, the only reason trolls are successful is because they know any legal costs are going to be far more than what they are attempting to extort, so the economics force most businesses to concede the fight.
I also strongly disagree that we need special rules for patent litigation. There is a rhyme and reason to the rules for cost shifting, one that doesn't depend on the subject matter of the litigation. What you seem to be implying is that patent litigants are less likely than other kind of litigants to being meritorious suits, and indeed that a patent suit is more likely than not non-meritorious. If that is the case, then the problem isn't who pays for a losing suit, but the law that creates enough wiggle room that these loser cases are being brought.
The way our litigation system fights meritless litigation is to make it relatively cheap to dispose of meritless suits. As an outsider to the practice, it seems to me that one of the big problems with patent suits in practice is that it's a relatively complex, fact-specific inquiry to determine patent validity. The usual way to address this is to add additional, easy to prove thresholds that let a case be dismissed without consideration of involved questions.