Beyond that, even if we accept the premise that it's easier for Zucker to give away $500MM than someone with little to donate a fraction of that amount, the money will absolutely have a great net impact on society as a whole. Isn't that contribution to the betterment of all worth a major celebration?
I think part of the problem is that it's hard to conceptualize what sort of impact donations as large as these will have. If we actually met the thousands of people that this gift will help out, and heard their stories of what a different it made, I think it'd be much harder to dismiss than it is a written number.
But (for example purposes - not targeting Zuck) why would you celebrate a person who is using a donation as a tax write-off?
If you throw money at a problem, often times you create a dependency on that aid, and other times you just end up with even more mouths to feed.
It's not that monetary aid is always 100% ineffective. It's just that once you tally up the bad and the good, you're left with something that's in the red.
Why do you think that's fine? Do you regard the notion that one person's happiness must be "paid for" by another person's suffering as a virtuous one?
The only exceptions I can think of are blood donations or anything where you're donating a 'human' element (visiting the elderly) rather than your work.
This isn't directed at Zuck or Facebook, or anything. Because I really don't know him.
But regarding your shock about the dollar amount...
Keep in mind that it's incredibly easy to be generous when you are at the top. It's actually so easy, that it's almost effortless.
There really is a difference between a man that writes a check that makes no difference to him (in the amount), and a man with nothing that roles up his sleeves, goes out, and dedicates himself to helping others.
I'll celebrate the latter before I'll celebrate the former.
One throws money away, the other helps change everyone around him.