Re:The Hobbit: Why 48FPS Makes Film Less Magical
by peroo on Wednesday December 19, 2012 @06:56AM
(#4942192)
> If the overarching plot is to kill a dragon, there are some difficulties when trying to stretch it out into 9 hours of films.
From what I've gathered the dragon will be dealt with in the second movie (hence the name), while the third movie will deal with the aftermath, as well as being padded with content from the LOTR appendix. Personally I think the first movie will make more sense in light of the sequels, though that of course doesn't really defend the somewhat lackluster nature of it.
Re:The Hobbit: Why 48FPS Makes Film Less Magical
by shpiel on Wednesday December 19, 2012 @08:42AM
(#4942487)
The portrayal of the dwarves is consistent with their characterization in the book.
Re:The Hobbit: Why 48FPS Makes Film Less Magical
by JshWright on Wednesday December 19, 2012 @08:56AM
(#4942550)
The point of The Hobbit wasn't defeating Smaug, it was the adventure along the way...
Re:The Hobbit: Why 48FPS Makes Film Less Magical
by pretoriusB on Wednesday December 19, 2012 @09:49AM
(#4942765)
What adventure? Leaving one place and going to another, with so ho-hum episodes in between?
Re:The Hobbit: Why 48FPS Makes Film Less Magical
by bjustin on Wednesday December 19, 2012 @09:54AM
(#4942795)
The title for The Hobbit (the book) is "The Hobbit or There and Back Again"[1]. It is about the journey.
[1] http://www.amazon.com/The-Hobbit-There-Back-Again/dp/0618150... or see the end of Return of the King where Frodo adds the "Lord of the Rings" title under Bilbo's title.
(Spoilers ahead.)
Bilbo and the dwarves were caricatures - overdoing their roles as a surprised hobbit and a fat, funny disney character with a single personality. (Seriously - there's a fat one, a stupid one, an Irish one, an old one etc...)
That would be ok, since The Hobbit is a children's book, but this is certainly not a children's film. I did not like the mixture of comedy and seriousness that was attempted. Whereas LOTR (which I really enjoyed) had moments of Merry and Pippin being funny, these dwarves never seemed to stop taking everything as a joke (obviously apart from Mr. Serious Dwarf). Some bits were genuinely funny (dwarves with Elrond), but they're in obviously safe environments.
If the overarching plot is to kill a dragon, there are some difficulties when trying to stretch it out into 9 hours of films. Sauron had a command structure and it was perfectly possible to kill mini-bosses (Saruman) and get some feel that you're doing something useful. A dragon has no such web of power, so the various evils they vanquish in the film appear disconnected and irrelevant to the main plot.
Gandalf has seemingly random amounts of power at any given time. I guess this also cropped up in LOTR, but it was much more obvious here.
Graphics for graphics sake. Rock battles?
Gollum was good.