The continuing difficulty the US military is having subduing militants in Afghanistan armed with relatively unsophisticated weapons suggests otherwise. A subtle, boiled-frog style slide in to totalitarianism is still possible, of course, but the direct approach would likely bring reasonably effective armed resistance.
A nuclear weapon, tank or drone is effective against an isolated base or compound, but when insurgents are mixed in with the population of a city, soldiers go after them with rifles. Very similar rifles are sold at Walmart[0].
That said, the self defense argument is more applicable to a modern society. Unfortunately, it turns out to be really difficult to evaluate its effectiveness. Comparisons to other countries are problematic due to the huge number of variables involved. Every study I've found purporting to offer a number of self defense incidents is severely and obviously flawed (studies with low numbers only count incidents where the police took a report of a crime; studies with high numbers include self-reported incidents of dubious veracity). The number of violent crimes in which a criminal was visibly armed falls between the high and low numbers for self defense, so it is not possible to say whether guns are used by civilians to stop crimes more often than to commit them.
One less-problematic correlation I've been able to find is that states enacting right-to-carry laws generally saw their murder rates fall faster than the national average afterward - often substantially faster, suggesting that the perception that any person might be armed provides a deterrent effect.
I can't even buy a fully automated machine gun.
The Supreme Court has not made an unambiguous ruling on whether or not you can have a machine gun. As the law is currently written, you cannot own a newly-manufactured machine gun as an ordinary civilian. DC v. Heller established a minimum level of protection - that guns in common use for lawful purposes cannot be banned - but not a maximum. US v. Miller suggests that guns suitable for militia purposes cannot be banned. Given that (selectively) fully-automatic rifles and light machine guns are the standard weapons for infantry soldiers, it is very likely that a legal challenge to this prohibition would succeed.
If Amendments can't be passed anymore (practically) then there is something broken about this country.
The last amendment was 20 years ago. That's not an unusually long time. I didn't mean that all amendments are impossibly difficult; I meant that a repeal of the Second Amendment would be impossibly difficult.
[0] http://www.walmart.com/ip/Sig-Sauer-M400-Enhanced-Carbine-OD...
That is my beef with that Amendment -- it doesn't apply anymore. It will not make a difference. One can say we have been slowly sliding towards totalitarianism (plutarchy maybe) and the fact that some people in Michigan are gathering regularly, putting face paint on and then shooting beer cans from AK-47s doesn't make a difference at all.
As you agreed Founding Fathers could not have predicted massive surveillance that would make Gestapo proud, satellites, tanks, nuclear weapons, etc. So in their time 100 militia people with rifles could take 100 government solders with rifles and it would be a nice match.
> Of course not. That's why we have courts.
Alright I agree only if the courts would correctly reinterpret the amendment and let me have a couple of nuclear weapons, some drones with weapons, tanks, and fighter planes. Because what is really meant by "arms" these day. But I can't even buy a fully automated machine gun.
To me personally, most times guns are used in this country against someone by a civilian they are used either by drunk family members against each other or by criminals.
> The authors of the Fourth Amendment probably couldn't have imagined laser microphones, but the courts have held that using one (or anything else high-tech) to eavesdrop on conversations you have in a private place is just like a search and requires a warrant.
But their hands are tied. So they can reinterpret the Second Amendment (which I have concluded they haven't as citizens don't get access to matching arms as the government does) but only up to a point. Like it can't reinterpret it so take away the guns. At some point if it is written it is followed blindly like some magic book from the sky.
The original article was trying to use the "reinterpretation loophole". I don't agree with using loopholes. But I agree with the intent (remove the weapons) by do it by fixing the Amendment. If Amendments can't be passed anymore (practically) then there is something broken about this country.
The way it is now, the Amendment does more harm than good.