News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TSA to Commission Independent Study of X-Ray Body Scanners by stcredzero on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @12:23PM (#4938475)
In all likelihood, the conclusion will be #3. If government agencies feel compelled to do such studies beforehand from now on, then change has occurred in the right direction.
Re:TSA to Commission Independent Study of X-Ray Body Scanners by nullc on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @01:51PM (#4938870)
If it's (3) saying in _zero_ harm then it's almost certantly a lie (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linear_no-threshold_model), if it's a (3) saying the harm is very low and so it wins on cost benefit — well, that is possible but it seems really unlikely considering how insanely low the base rate of terrorism is, much less the subset of attacks which the scanners actually prevent (vs just shuffling around the attack mechanisms).
Re:TSA to Commission Independent Study of X-Ray Body Scanners by glenra on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @02:54PM (#4939239)
It's actually plausible that the scanners - if working as designed - might cause net health benefit ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiation_hormesis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hormesis ).

The tricky thing is that we have no way of knowing if the machines are operating as designed and the powers that be have a looooong history of outright lying to passengers. I still remember when they told people sending your camera through the X-ray wasn't bad for the film - this was a lie, but it made security's job easier to tell that lie, so they told it. Knowing that the TSA is a bunch of incompetent and untrustworthy nitwits, I don't trust them to operate dangerous equipment safely. Since a machine that's not being maintained correctly or isn't being used correctly could be really dangerous, I generally choose to opt out.

Re:TSA to Commission Independent Study of X-Ray Body Scanners by pdonis on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @02:03PM (#4938959)
it seems really unlikely considering how insanely low the base rate of terrorism is, much less the subset of attacks which the scanners actually prevent

This is an argument for not screening passengers, or at least doing it very differently from the way we do now. It's not an argument for using one type of scanner rather than another, given that you are going to screen with scanners. That's the only question at issue in the OP: whether TSA should use X-ray scanners or another type.

Re:TSA to Commission Independent Study of X-Ray Body Scanners by gknoy on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @03:21PM (#4939384)
If more people are likely to die per year from cancer caused by the scanners than are likely to die from terrorists, I think that's a convincing argument that using the scanners screen passengers is worse than not screening them at all.
Re:TSA to Commission Independent Study of X-Ray Body Scanners by pdonis on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @03:59PM (#4939543)
using the scanners screen passengers is worse than not screening them at all.

Sure, that's true (given your assumptions) if the scanners pose any risk that's worse than just walking a distance equivalent to the space taken up by the checkpoint. But as I said, that's not the question under discussion; the question is whether there is any significant difference between one type of scanner and another, given that you're going to scan passengers.

Re:TSA to Commission Independent Study of X-Ray Body Scanners by stcredzero on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @02:22PM (#4939049)
The cost/benefit is likely to be different between the X-ray backs after and millimeter wave scanners.
Re:TSA to Commission Independent Study of X-Ray Body Scanners by pdonis on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @03:59PM (#4939548)
Different, sure. But different doesn't necessarily mean better.
Re:TSA to Commission Independent Study of X-Ray Body Scanners by jlgreco on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @05:04PM (#4939853)
Explain how risk/reward could be different without one being better than the other. Is one going to come out as an imaginary number or something?

Actually, now that I think about it more, you're probably going to be dividing by zero to calculate that risk over reward so testing equality will be a challenge...

Re:TSA to Commission Independent Study of X-Ray Body Scanners by pdonis on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @05:20PM (#4939922)
Because risk/reward requires tradeoffs; it isn't a single linear scale. Different tradeoffs can be judged differently based on who is doing the judging and what criteria they are using. There isn't a single "right answer".
Re:TSA to Commission Independent Study of X-Ray Body Scanners by jlgreco on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @05:31PM (#4939986)
For anyone's subjective answer, one is going to be better than the other, unless they are freakishly identical. Whoever provides the most rational defense of their analysis is the person we listen to.

We don't need to play fast and loose with the calculation though. Real data would be trivial to accumulate, were it permitted.