Re:No, Really, Regulate the Bullets
by staunch on Monday December 17, 2012 @10:25PM
(#4935885)
Arguing about the merits of second amendment (or first amendment, for that matter) is reasonable. Suggesting that the government pass laws that subvert The Constitution is not.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:No, Really, Regulate the Bullets
by arjunnarayan on Monday December 17, 2012 @10:37PM
(#4935918)
Right. This is the Scalia philosophy. Don't like the constitution? Go ahead and amend it.
This is the American philosophy. We've been amending The Constitution since shortly after it was created.
Re:No, Really, Regulate the Bullets
by jack-r-abbit on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @02:00PM
(#4938935)
True. Even the gun control issue is hovering around the 2nd Amendment. And then there was the whole amendment to ban alcohol that was then reversed with yet another amendment. So... let's not get locked into some false idea that things can't be changed. We need to focus on what changes (if any) make sense and when. Maybe changes don't make sense right now... but if the first argument is "but the Constitution says so" then look at what actually got it to say so... it was a change.