News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Andreessen and Mixpanel Call for an End to “Bullshit Metr... by bryanh on Monday December 17, 2012 @04:08PM (#4934373)
I really love Mixpanel, it is the "best in breed" when it comes to event analytics. I don't think many people would argue with that, it's awesome. In fact, we use it at Zapier for pretty much everything (basic funnels, A/B testing, retention, engagement, etc...) and we haven't even reached our full potential with it yet. But I still have some pretty fundamental beefs with the state of analytics software in general.

About the article, the problem stems from the fact that proper analytics is hard and is (arguably) getting harder with more advanced packages.Shouldn't it be going in the opposite direction?

It is a lot easier to track discrete downloads or pageviews than some other, more insightful metric, so people will naturally gravitate to the cheaper metrics. Until this is reversed, bullshit metrics will reign.

Anyways, my beefs:

First: how do you decide what data to send into the package?

The more data you send, the better (sure), but at a certain point you are just duplicating your internal datastore, so that is too much, right? But not enough and you'll miss a chance to understand a phenomena that you didn't predict seeing (isn't that the point?). After you decide, then you write a crapton of code to send it all (what about backfilling data when you want to track something new?).

Second: once you are collecting the data, how do you know what metrics to actively track?

This is definitely existential, but it's back to the core problem: doing analytics properly is hard. Why couldn't the software let me define some properties about the type of app I am running and suggest some strategies (you have a subscription SaaS app? Try tracking paid plan retention, signup funnels, etc...). Maybe it could go even further with reverse funnels, as in: what events are the most important and work backwards. I could see some automation and discovery possibilities there.

Third: do I really have to dig around trying to find something useful?

All the data is there, the software should tell me what is useful or interesting. It's definitely a hard problem, but I would throw money at software that could send me this email: "Looks like users who experienced event "ABC" also performed your highest priority event "Signup" at a 13% higher rate. This observation is 99% confident." Of course, you'd need to investigate a littler deeper to see if that isn't just a fluke or something stupidly obvious (like: people who view a page signup at a higher rate than those who don't), but at least I might learn something.

I know this is certainly a pipe dream as of today, but I vow to shower someone with money if they can do this.

In my opinion, the next generation of analytics software won't just have more bells and whistles, it will fundamentally shorten the time to some sort of real "AHA!" insight.

Re:Andreessen and Mixpanel Call for an End to “Bullshit Metr... by suhail on Monday December 17, 2012 @04:23PM (#4934458)
We deal with this every day at Mixpanel. Education is a tough problem to solve. Here's how we think about it with respect to your questions:

"First: how do you decide what data to send into the package?"

My recommendation is you think about this gradually. Don't instrument everything. Start by picking 5 metrics you really, really care about. One of them should be your One Key Metric (OKM) - a metric that you would be the company on if you could only pick one thing to measure. I think the pressure of picking 5 helps you decide what to measure.

"Second: once you are collecting the data, how do you know what metrics to actively track?"

When you start gradually, there isn't much to pay attention to. Stay focused only on a set of metrics. Add more metrics when you want to understand those specific metrics more deeply. Add more data to split those metrics into groups to dig even deeper. Keep driving your OKM up as much as possible--sometimes you have to do it with something that correlates to it.

"Third: do I really have to dig around trying to find something useful?"

Today, the answer is yes. Businesses are fundamentally very different. Analytics is a lot like science experiments in high school: You start with a hypothesis, you test to see if you were right, and if you were then you came up with a conclusion or answer to your experiment. It's hard work to build a good business. I think the first step is for companies like us to help you understand your data. The next step that I think is more important than simply pulling "insights" out automatically is to help you take action on it so you grow.

Re:Andreessen and Mixpanel Call for an End to “Bullshit Metr... by smalter on Monday December 17, 2012 @07:43PM (#4935449)
As a fan and free user of Mixpanel (so take my comment with a grain of salt), I really wish you guys would do more with education.

A simple library of use cases with how to implement them in Mixpanel would be an awesome start. No coding required, just need a someone to write these.

For instance, I had a question about how to track the effectiveness of different blog posts. When a user signed up, I wanted to know which blog posts (if any) that user had read. This is useful because content is the biggest driver of signups for us.

I couldn't find any info anywhere on how to do this with Mixpanel or any other analytics tool. I emailed Mixpanel support and got an immediate & thoughtful response from Woody (which was awesome), but I would've much preferred if there were a self-serve library.

Re:Andreessen and Mixpanel Call for an End to “Bullshit Metr... by bryanh on Monday December 17, 2012 @06:15PM (#4935081)
Thanks for the response.

I just signed up fresh to Mixpanel to play around and you guys have solid technical on-boarding around just installing and collecting any data, but not a lot of details on what to collect. I'm sure that getting someone to collect just anything is a better first step than some sort of high level tutorial, which is why you do it that way.

I like the OKM idea a lot. Perhaps that could be a pretty solid center stone for on-boarding a new user. I just remember being overwhelmed by the blank slate every time I signed up for any analytics package.

Re:Andreessen and Mixpanel Call for an End to “Bullshit Metr... by suhail on Monday December 17, 2012 @06:41PM (#4935192)
We generally reach out on the support side proactively to help. Anyone on our team is happy to think it through for you.

If you want to learn more in the abstract we recently came out with an education series: http://mixpanel.com/education

Re:Andreessen and Mixpanel Call for an End to “Bullshit Metr... by bialecki on Monday December 17, 2012 @05:20PM (#4934768)
It's going to get better, this whole thing is still very early. Two things we focus on at Klaviyo to make taking all the data you have more useful:

1. Come up with the questions first, then decide what data you need to answer them. It's so now easy to track every mouse movement of your users that a lot of people just track everything assuming they'll find something useful later. It doesn't usually work that way. More is not better, it's distracting. Even worse, people tend to pick the easiest things to track, which aren't the most useful. If you start from a question and backtrack, it might be more work, but you'll definitely get something useful out of it.

Coming up with question isn't always easy. We're trying an experiment to help people with questions via an analytics/engagement "Cookbook" (http://www.klaviyo.com/cookbook). You pick a question, fill in the variables and then we tell you what to track to answer it. We're still fleshing it out, but that's one idea we've got.

2. Don't look at analytics only in retrospect, use them actively. People don't make most decision at a single point in time, it's about building enough momentum to catalyze action. Because of that, you can do a lot more if you have a way to communicate with them and can effectively leverage what you know to build that momentum. Someone doesn't sign up? When they come back, can you show them content based on what they didn't do last time (e.g. viewed pricing page, but not feature tour...highlight the feature tour). Someone signs up and doesn't get completely set up? Are you sending them an email with instructions tailored to where they stopped and why they might have stopped there.

Related side note: I've gotten plenty of emails after signing up for something asking if I want "help." While it's a nice gesture, as more people send those emails, it gets old fast. Why can't you use what I've done so far to anticipate the questions I might have or give me reasons to get back on the horse?