News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by vrganj on Sunday August 16, 2026 @05:05AM (#49318264)
I have come to the same conclusion, but let me ask you, how can you still be a capitalist having had that insight?

Why would you support a system that you recognize makes it impossible to do the right thing even as we're dying from its consequences?

Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by dgellow on Sunday August 16, 2026 @07:40AM (#49319098)
I honestly don’t know and feel very conflicted about my own ideology. I recognize how broken it is at scale, but also value the personal autonomy, entrepreneurship, nonconformity capitalism promotes.

Though my version of capitalism isn’t the libertarian free market one, libertarianism will always evolve into oligarchy or something fascistic given enough time, it’s just baked into the incentives.

My personal ideology aligns with a managed capitalism, markets are created by an authority that ensures the incentives aligns with its overall goals. Mixed with very liberal social values.

I don’t know if that can survive overtime though. And that would very likely degenerate into something else when under stress.

As I said, I feel conflicted. But I appreciate the question

Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by hliyan on Sunday August 16, 2026 @07:57AM (#49319198)
Perhaps this will help: commerce, free market and capitalism are three different things. Commerce, or trade, has existed for millennia, even among tribes and villages. The free market emerges when there are multiple producers of a good or service, and there is no compulsion upon any producer (from either a third party or another producer) to buy or sell. Capitalism would be when one or more of these producers no longer need to engage in production themselves, but are able to use their surplus savings to employ other producers and then keep for themselves the difference between market price and production cost (including cost of labor). There is nothing inherently wrong with that latter mode of production, except that it never reaches a dynamic equilibrium. Since it's surplus savings that enable the acquisition and direction of other producers (i.e. their labor), and that process leads to additional surpluses, the accumulation of surplus becomes exponential. At some point, the surplus becomes sufficient to apply compulsion on other producers, thus effectively eroding the free market that led to that mode of production in the first place.
Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by vrganj on Sunday August 16, 2026 @08:02AM (#49319240)
I really appreciate the self-reflective answer and I fully understand the conflict.

You seem like a thoughtful dude, kudos.

I fully agree with your assessment about capitalism inevitably devolving into either fascism or some sort of feudalism.

I, too, have been struggling with what a more just system could look like.

Personally, some aspects of Yugoslav worker self-management appeal to me.

Basic idea is: Companies compete on a market, but theres no stock market. Companies <= 5 employees can be run however the founders envisioned, past that boundary the board and exec suite are required to be elected by the workers.

Combined with state grants and regulations to direct the overall direction of the economy, I feel like it solves for a lot of issues of shareholder capitalism without swapping them for a whole separate set of Commissariat problems.

Of course, the state itself wasn't democratic in Yugoslavia and it suffered from ethnic tensions that ultimately tore it apart. But we don't need to copy their setup wholesale.

Wonder how you'd feel about something like that?

Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by nec4b on Sunday August 16, 2026 @12:02PM (#49321237)
Yugoslavia failed spectacularly economically. People had to smuggle bananas, diapers, coffee and jeans among other goods from the neighboring Italy and Austria. Millions of people (Gastarbeiter) migrated to Germany to be able support their families, because there was no opportunity at home. Inflation was horrendous, people exchanged the local currency to german marks on the same day as the payday, otherwise by the next day it was worth half as much. There was a shortage of gasoline and people sometimes waited years to get a car. But yes the dictator and the red nobility lived very well for sure.
Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by vrganj on Sunday August 16, 2026 @12:16PM (#49321368)
First of all, as already acknowledged above Yugoslavia wasn't perfect - I'm not sure what you're trying to get at here. As already mentioned, I'm not arguing for copying their entire setup wholesale - I just find the specific bits I pointed out interesting. Democracy comes was both invented and then repopularized by societies of slave holders, but that doesn't mean we have to throw out the baby with the bath water!

Inflation was horrendous in many countries, including lots of very capitalist ones. Think Weimar Germany for a famous example, or the Latin American debt crises of the 80s and 90s for ones contemporaneous with Yugoslavia (note also the IMF involvement here)

In the case of Yugoslavia, there's a good argument to be made that the root cause were western trade barriers as part of the successful plan to push it into IMF loans that could then be used to dismantle the country.

Anyways, why are we even religitating the 20th century? We need to be looking forward and figuring out a solution to the crisis right in front of us instead of going all cold war again. The forest are burning right now. The rivers are running low right now. Yugoslavia, however you may feel about it, ended decades ago.

Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by nec4b on Sunday August 16, 2026 @05:58PM (#49324128)
You brought the failed state of Yugoslavia as model. I don't have a clue why though. Its economic model certainly doesn't solve any of the existing problems and it would exacerbate them. The forest will burn and rivers will run dry as long as this planet will exist. You are acting as if this is not a naturally occurring phenomena.
Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by vrganj on Sunday August 16, 2026 @06:45PM (#49324522)
It isn't.

And surely, you know that as well. Then why this farce? Ideological commitment?

Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by nec4b on Monday August 17, 2026 @03:03PM (#49336004)
A country that can't provide basic goods like bananas and coffee, needs to send millions of it's people to another country so they can survive, represses minorities and political dissidents, has Lukasenko type of dictator for life as president and finally bankrupts and violently disintegrates with a genocide is a definition of a failed state. I do ideologicaly oppose to such a system to be revived, it would be criminal to want that.
Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by vrganj on Tuesday August 18, 2026 @03:36AM (#49342611)
What are you even talking about? We were talking about approaches to the climate crisis and you responded by denying it even exists and going on long rants about Lukashenko's bananas?

Could you please be a bit more constructive and solutions-oriented?

The rivers are drying out. I'm sure you saw the news. Can we please not derail this to talk about your pet topic? The Cold War is over, move on. We got our own problems in the 21st century.

Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by nec4b on Tuesday August 18, 2026 @11:06AM (#49346735)
Again you brought it up.
Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by kakacik on Sunday August 16, 2026 @09:09AM (#49319725)
This is what Europe has, in one way or another. Europe is a huge spread - sort of semi-functional communism/socialism that France has for example, and it has nothing to do with more capitalistic approach of say Switzerland. Economies and their state show this very well over time.

Every system is potentially broken, there is always room for it to go extreme in some way. The last thing I would want in Europe is for of unhinged corrupted oligarchy that US has - common folks are squeezed like there is no tomorrow, crappy healthcare and expensive education, almost no chance to escape their allotted class within system based on income ('american dream' is not really... realistic to be polite and I could easily use a word 'lie' there, just to keep poor desperate masses in check around the elections or during crises). Maximization of pure income to suffer in literally every single other aspect that makes society a well working society long term - no thank you, we can and do get it better overall.

So one has to be realistic, there is no ideal system, Swiss system of minimal centralized power that is frequently changing hands is, as many things Swiss had come up with, IMHO the most resilient for the future. Any counter-argument to that can be easily dealt with the reality of frequent public votes on all major topics. If you follow their politics a bit its lightyears ahead of typical cesspool US or EU politics had become daily. But one can't have this system (or any other) without underlying population making it work, day by day, out in the streets. Swiss have it working, work actively and hard on preserving it as much as possible, again not something I see elsewhere, certainly not in EU.

Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by vixen99 on Sunday August 16, 2026 @05:34AM (#49318431)
You're not going to do anything at all without money as a fungible exchange mechanism (a sometime measure of 'value'). Capitalists see value in things and try to generate that value. Yes, politicians and the rest of us have the job of regulating that process and sometime fail to do a good job. Do you know the right thing to do? I doubt it. You seriously do not see this as an immensely complicated issue? Finally please give chapter and verse for the 'dying'. Maybe compare the world of 2026 with that of 1900 and the quality of life for people in general and our concern for the life on this planet. Concern isn't action but it's a necessary prerequisite for it.
Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by dgellow on Sunday August 16, 2026 @07:41AM (#49319108)
Money and value exist in all economical systems and has existed in some form since immemorial times, that has literally nothing to do with capitalism, an ideology developed over the past 250y or so
Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by xfil on Sunday August 16, 2026 @10:51AM (#49320668)
Also, our current system grossly undermines the functionality of our market economy. A lack of pricing for negative externalities will essentially always result in the basic concept of market failure.

Run inaccurate pricing of carbon emissions long enough and something bad is bound to happen. Same ordeal with cattle ranching & agriculture to feed it in the Amazon basin: >20% of the 55-million-year-old Amazon rainforest has been degraded for cattle in the past 55 years, partially because consumers don't pay accurate prices and producers don't pay accurate costs.

The unwillingness to merely partially solve obvious market failures via accurate pricing is a catastrophic hypocrisy in those among us who thump their chests about 'free markets' while conflating the concept with modern capitalism.

Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by vrganj on Sunday August 16, 2026 @06:27AM (#49318711)
> Capitalists see value in things and try to generate that value

Value for who? Value as determined by who?

> Finally please give chapter and verse for the 'dying'.

You're commenting on it right now. Rivers here are drying out. Glaciers are melting. Forests are burning. How long do you think we can keep going like this?

> Maybe compare the world of 2026 with that of 1900 and the quality of life for people in general and our concern for the life on this planet.

You can compare the results of those 126 years right here: https://static01.nyt.com/images/2023/01/23/learning/GlobalTe...

Regarding your quality of life claim, let me refer back to the burning forests, drying rivers etc. Would you call that an improvement?

Clearly, its not going great. And action is actively being sabotaged by the most capitalist major power: https://www.nytimes.com/2025/11/06/climate/trump-climate-int...

So how do we proceed with all this in mind?

How long can we keep optimizing for capital self-reproduction at the expense of the base conditions we survive on? The incentive structure does not allow for making the systemic changes required for continued thriving of humanity. What good is it then? How is it anything but a suicide pact?

Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by nec4b on Sunday August 16, 2026 @12:09PM (#49321305)
>>Value for who? Value as determined by who?

Value for us, real people who have needs. We decide what we want to buy and not some apparatchik on their pedestal.

>>Rivers here are drying out. Glaciers are melting. Forests are burning.

As if this never happened before capitalism?

Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by vrganj on Sunday August 16, 2026 @12:14PM (#49321350)
Who is "us"? Because in capitalism, only people with capital get to decide what has value.

The values of the poor are not reflected. The values of the indigenous are not reflected. The values of the non-capitalist are not reflected. The value of the unborn is not reflected. The value of nature is not reflected.

The glacier doesn't participate in the market and neither does the river. Are they without value?

> As if this never happened before capitalism?

That's correct. Look at the graph I posted above, you'll notice that things weren't always this hot. Before capitalism they sure weren't.

Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by nec4b on Sunday August 16, 2026 @05:51PM (#49324067)
No, every one participates. Ordinary people the most, because the capitalist first and foremost need to provide value to us. I'm not sure what do you mean by rivers, glaciers or others not participating in the market? Isn't it evident people assign great value to natural resources. The world is a bit older then 120 years in your graph. There were a lot of natural disasters that wiped quite a lot of living beings from the planet.
Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by vrganj on Sunday August 16, 2026 @06:38PM (#49324485)
> No, every one participates. Ordinary people the most

That is just straight up not true. The tribal elder in the Amazon, who's forest capitalists are burning down never got asked how he defines value. The child not yet born was never asked if it's atmosphere should be heated up for data centers. Neither was the fish in the river or the river itself for that matter.

> what do you mean by rivers, glaciers or others not participating in the market?

I'm not sure what's unclear. The glacier melts as a result of somebody who's not the glacier deciding "value" on a market. In reality, the market doesn't decide value. Value is not price. The market decides power structures and violence distribution. The glacier has a value completely separate from the market, and not derived from it.

> There were a lot of natural disasters

Why are we pivoting to natural disasters now?

Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by nec4b on Monday August 17, 2026 @02:55PM (#49335881)
How exactly can you ask an unborn child, a river or a glacier what it wants? Did the Yugoslav dictator ask Kosovars what they want before violently oppressing them?
Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by vrganj on Tuesday August 18, 2026 @03:09AM (#49342371)
That is precisely the point - you can't! I'm glad we got to this shared understanding in the end.

So I'd appreciate if we stopped pretending the market did, when it fails to account for anything that's not somebody with money.

How could it possibly assign "value" that way?

Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by nec4b on Tuesday August 18, 2026 @11:08AM (#49346775)
So which economical system enables us to talk to inanimate objects or unborn babies, since you think this is a fault of capitalism? You have a deep misunderstanding of markets and capitalism!
Re:Super El Niño Keeps Growing as New Forecasts Reach Record... by marcosdumay on Sunday August 16, 2026 @06:00PM (#49324143)
You can't be a neo-liberal.

Despite what people keep repeating on the internet, capitalism is a very general idea, and growth at all costs is not a value from it exactly.