News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Empirical Evidence for the Value of Version Control? by raverbashing on Monday December 17, 2012 @03:39AM (#4931417)
I think anyone who questions the need for an "empirical evidence" has never written a single line of code in their life

Because it's in plain sight

No, this is not a matter of "trying to find it"

If someone questions this they're already wrong.

Re:Empirical Evidence for the Value of Version Control? by CJefferson on Monday December 17, 2012 @03:43AM (#4931425)
While I agree there is a clear need for version control, telling someone looking for evidence that they are already wrong is extremely unhelpful.

Almost everyone had a time when they didn't use version control, at least not properly. I wrote thousands of lines of code on an Amstrad CPC, and the closest I came to version control was cycling between two different tapes when it came to saving my data. When I moved to PC I did the same, with two floppy discs.

Re:Empirical Evidence for the Value of Version Control? by raverbashing on Monday December 17, 2012 @04:11AM (#4931486)
So you see that even when you had no idea of what was version control you invented a rudimentary form of it?

That's the thing, that is so basic people invent it if they don't have it.

I did similar things, though not on an Amstrad ;)

Re:Empirical Evidence for the Value of Version Control? by sliverstorm on Monday December 17, 2012 @04:36AM (#4931568)
I agree that the lack of empirical evidence is probably because it's a pretty fundamental idea that is "common knowledge", but that doesn't mean evidence isn't useful and it also doesn't mean the original poster deserves a bashing.
Re:Empirical Evidence for the Value of Version Control? by baddox on Monday December 17, 2012 @03:53AM (#4931442)
> I think anyone who questions the need for an "empirical evidence" has never written a single line of code in their life

Just like anyone who questions the need for empirical evidence of the miasma theory has never worked around sick people a day in their life.

Re:Empirical Evidence for the Value of Version Control? by pekk on Monday December 17, 2012 @03:59AM (#4931451)
While miasma theory has been falsified, it was based on phenomena which were real and would have been stupid to deny.

If you can 'preserve the phenomena' that cause almost every serious producer of software to use version control, by some mechanism other than version control, with any kind of advantage whatsoever, everyone will be extremely interested because you are in a position to revolutionize the way software is made.

In reality the alternative to version control, particularly with multiple people touching the same files, is an insane mess, which is the reason we stick to these tools. This isn't to say that empirical evidence is not required, rather that the phenomena are so obvious and omnipresent that any idiot can gather them easily.

Re:Empirical Evidence for the Value of Version Control? by raverbashing on Monday December 17, 2012 @04:15AM (#4931498)
"While miasma theory has been falsified, it was based on phenomena which were real and would have been stupid to deny."

Exactly!

Miasma theory is incorrect, but it doesn't mean you can stand around sick people and won't get sick.

"ather that the phenomena are so obvious and omnipresent that any idiot can gather them easily."

Thank you.