News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by jQueryIsAwesome on Monday December 17, 2012 @01:59AM (#4931163)
What is with you Americans and the Constitution? If back then female circumcision would have been considered a good idea and somehow got wrote in the constitution then you will be defending it now days because it is in the constitution?

If the constitution is wrong, it needs to be changed, is just that simple.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by aharrison on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:07AM (#4931196)
The reason we Americans are so strongly tied to our Constitution is multifaceted, but one of the key tenets is that it is a so called "living document" and allows itself to be modified via an amendment. The criticism that it should not be made illegal is a criticism that we are directly in violation of a document with extremely clear language. Instead of doing so, we should do the "correct" thing and pass an amendment to correct the original language with our current up-to-date understanding.

It is my personal opinion that the reason we don't is because enough people disagree with modifying it, and so it has to be curtailed slowly (rightly or wrongly.)

Re:"Gun" "Control" by sliverstorm on Monday December 17, 2012 @03:51AM (#4931439)
You hit on a good point, the Constitution is seen as invioble. You can tweak it, but you can't start striking pieces down.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by rmc on Monday December 17, 2012 @04:26AM (#4931537)
What's funny is that many changes were pretty fundamental legal changes, such as the abolition of slavery, massively extending the right to vote, allowing a wide range of pornography & allowing abortion & contraception. To claim those as "merely updating our understanding of what the founding fathers wanted" is misleading, but eh, if it makes you sleep at night.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by sliverstorm on Monday December 17, 2012 @04:29AM (#4931546)
I'm not sure how you could call those changes "fundamental". Some of them were pretty far-reaching in terms of resulting impact, but they did not fundamentally alter the Constitution.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by rmc on Monday December 17, 2012 @05:23AM (#4931707)
They altered US society in some pretty massive ways, altered who controlled the government, and had large and fundamental impact on many people's lives.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by sliverstorm on Monday December 17, 2012 @05:42AM (#4931770)
Yes, but did the alter the core concepts of the document?
Re:"Gun" "Control" by rmc on Monday December 17, 2012 @07:50AM (#4932056)
Well, that's a debatable point. What is the core concept? That the people should elect the government? Well it went from white landowning males electing the government to all adults (excl. prisoners)? Does that count?
Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:09AM (#4931203)
>If the constitution is wrong, it needs to be changed, is just that simple.

Yep. And there are two methods for doing just that. But they both require a fair degree of consensus, and in the US the consensus in recent years has shifted toward more freedom regarding firearms instead of less.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by baddox on Monday December 17, 2012 @04:02AM (#4931459)
You should be a bit clearer about what you mean. There's a big difference between advocating that the government ignore the Constitution, and advocating a constitutional amendment. Your last sentence hints at the latter, which is hopefully your position, but "obsession with the Constitution" would by definition include the willingness to amend it, since the amendment process is itself contained in the Constitution.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by angersock on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:04AM (#4931178)
I don't believe anybody here would disagree with you--now, please explain to what degree you believe the 2nd amendment to be wrong, right, or outdated.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by mpweiher on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:14AM (#4931219)
Well...

(a) the US seems to working its way to tyranny just fine with the 2nd amendment intact.

(b) many other countries seem to do a pretty passable imitation of freedom without a 2nd amendment.

Update:

(c) on closer examination, it almost seems like an "opiate for the people" kind of thing: people being lulled into thinking they are free because they can kill innocent children with their high-powered weapons when the fact is that actual armed insurrection against the government is as ludicrously impossible with those weapons as it is without.

At the same time, real freedoms have been largely eliminated, habeas corpus is gone, 4th amendment largely gone, freedom of speech going away, freedom of assembly AWOL, elections manipulated and legislators bought, the president can have anyone incarcerated indefinitely without charges and without a trial, or summarily executed by simply labeling them a "terrorist" (and those labels fly looser every day). Focusing on these issues will have a much larger impact on actual liberty than trying to prevent meaningful gun control.

Yet, yay, we are "free" because we have our Glocks. Yeah, right.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by angersock on Monday December 17, 2012 @12:18PM (#4933197)
Surely you see the irony in complaining about the erosion of these liberties while at the same time pushing for further subjugation of the populace?
Re:"Gun" "Control" by mpweiher on Monday December 17, 2012 @06:28PM (#4935127)
Surely you see the irony of completely missing the point of what I wrote?
Re:"Gun" "Control" by rmc on Monday December 17, 2012 @04:27AM (#4931540)
Lots of people are dying.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by angersock on Monday December 17, 2012 @12:23PM (#4933231)
Every day, from heart disease, and car accidents, and lung cancer, and diabetes, and all manner of other things.

As far as bang-for-your-buck legislation goes, we should look elsewhere if we want to decrease bodycounts.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by rmc on Monday December 17, 2012 @01:32PM (#4933562)
Laws and public policy is being made to tackle those things. Should we not tackle the other deaths (being caused by guns) as well?
Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Monday December 17, 2012 @03:44PM (#4934255)
Not if it means we have to give up freedoms. The problem just isn't that significant.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by jQueryIsAwesome on Monday December 17, 2012 @09:23PM (#4935728)
"freedoms"; what a concept, freedom to what exactly? freedom to easily kill I am guessing... because that being the case you should allow the posetion and creation of nuclear weapons by any USA citizen; those things give a lot of freedom to kill.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Monday December 17, 2012 @10:33PM (#4935910)
Freedom to self defense is pretty fundamental in my book. As we like to say, when seconds count the police are only minutes away.

It's probably different in your country, with no crime or violence or anything.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by jQueryIsAwesome on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @01:35AM (#4936329)
Funny you mention my country; because just here in my City, the 3° biggest of South America, the amount of murders have reduced significantly since the ban of weapons in the streets; its called Bogota.

And you can keep playing to the hypothesis that someday you will need a revolution and guns will be useful, in real life in the present there is just people dying because you have associated your national identity with abusing gunpowder.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @04:28AM (#4936727)
Again, it just doesn't happen often enough that we need new laws.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by jQueryIsAwesome on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @07:11AM (#4937146)
Check your data more closely.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/2/20/Ush...

>"it just doesn't happen often enough"

There is nothing positive about guns; your group illusion of "self-protection" is quickly diminish by the fact that legal guns many times end up in the hands of the criminals, provoking accidents or in hands of mentally unqualified people... so even 1 death is enough.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @12:22PM (#4938462)
My data is just fine, thank you.

>There is nothing positive about guns; your group illusion of "self-protection" is quickly diminish by the fact that legal guns many times end up in the hands of the criminals, provoking accidents or in hands of mentally unqualified people... so even 1 death is enough.

The idea that "even 1 death is enough" to take away a basic human right is just plain idiotic. How many times have assaults and murders been deterred by a gun? That doesn't show up in homicide statistics, does it?

Re:"Gun" "Control" by jQueryIsAwesome on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @06:24PM (#4940260)
How many times a gun has ended in murderer's hands after being bought legally? That doesn't show up in homicide statistics either, does it?

Human rights as popularly known are the global rights established by the UN and I am pretty sure they don't mention guns. Or it must be a list of human rights you created yourself that I am not aware of.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @06:44PM (#4940348)
>How many times a gun has ended in murderer's hands after being bought legally? That doesn't show up in homicide statistics either, does it?

Eh, actually they show up in homicide statistics as, you know, homicides.

>Human rights as popularly known are the global rights established by the UN and I am pretty sure they don't mention guns.

The UN has no particular legitimacy in the recognition of rights. Human rights are intrinsic, so to a certain extent they're subjective. Clearly you don't believe the right to self defense is a human right, but I think most people would disagree with you.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by jQueryIsAwesome on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @09:45PM (#4940891)
> Eh, actually they show up in homicide statistics as, you know, homicides.

Just like you have your own human rights maybe this is from your own statistics too because the cdc.gov and other recognized institutions show nothing about the legality of the weapons used in murderess.

Human rights are the rights that should be respected by anyone; if you need some sort of self-defense by definition you are taking actions derived from a violation of your rights; so your self-defense is already out of any kind of human rights paradigm.

And self-defense is one of the most ambiguous concepts there are; if Palestinians could use an atomic bomb in Israel it would be self-defense? I think it would be, but it also would be wrong, very wrong.

USA is the developed country with the highest death rate by gunshots[1]; as much as you like to believe your own words data is not at your side.

[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_firearm-re...

Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Thursday December 20, 2012 @12:28AM (#4946406)
>Human rights are the rights that should be respected by anyone; if you need some sort of self-defense by definition you are taking actions derived from a violation of your rights; so your self-defense is already out of any kind of human rights paradigm.

There's no logic in that statement. I have a right to self defense, and for the state to deprive me of the means of self defense is a violation of my rights.

>USA is the developed country with the highest death rate by gunshots

Irrelevant. I don't care about suicides or legitimate shoots. For the purposes of this discussion only murders matter.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by jQueryIsAwesome on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:22AM (#4931240)
I was just answering to OP who talked like the fact that it is on the constitution is somehow a valid reason not to change the law.

>Finally, I'm sorry to say this and I know it gets old, but the U.S. constitution identifies a right to keep and bear arms.

But ok; I am going to pile on the other hundreds of comments making noise and tell you what I think America should do.

Decriminalize all drugs first (or at the same time). Then change the constitution and proclaim nobody should have guns except the police/military and some special cases (some bodyguards, bank guards); despite the popularity of "guns don't kill people" is pretty clear that where guns are the number of gunshot victims are always higher. Anyone who thinks they can overthrow the USA government from inside is delusional, before there is even 1000 people organized all forms of communication would be shout down; even internet. Your only hope to overthrow the USA government if such thing ever is required is that some generals and soldiers of the USA army itself revel.

Obviously this change would need to happen gradually; first the high caliber guns and then progressively the others; the government should pay for the guns so citizens have one more incentive to give them away.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by baddox on Monday December 17, 2012 @04:14AM (#4931497)
> Anyone who thinks they can overthrow the USA government from inside is delusional, before there is even 1000 people organized all forms of communication would be shout down; even internet.

"Overthrowing the government" makes it sound like an offensive operation, which is indeed fairly impractical. However, the real value of a large armed population is that it makes martial law and military occupation extremely difficult. It's a defensive advantage against an oppressive government. Look at the difficulty the US military has faced in its attempts to occupy Iraq, with a much smaller, poorer, and less sophisticated armed population. If the US government wanted to simply commit genocide against its population, sure, it could use chemical or nuclear weapons with little chance of civilian resistance, but there's not a huge advantage for even the most insane oppressive regime to do that.

> Then change the constitution and proclaim nobody should have guns except the police/military and some special cases (some bodyguards, bank guards).

Constitution or not, this is a deeply disturbing recommendation for many reasons, the most obvious of which is the fact that many people use guns for subsistence or income supplementation.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by jff on Monday December 17, 2012 @03:12AM (#4931357)
Yes, boil that frog slowly, and drug him first so he really won't realize it's happening.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by tomp on Monday December 17, 2012 @03:56AM (#4931446)
The frog is already being boiled. And it's drugged by FUD of media and propaganda.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by jQueryIsAwesome on Monday December 17, 2012 @03:55AM (#4931445)
It isn't nice to pretend you could overthrow your government, yeah, is nice as "religion" nice, as "delusional but thankfully uncheckable" nice.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Monday December 17, 2012 @03:43PM (#4934242)
I don't see any reason why we couldn't overthrow our government. It happens all over the world on a regular basis. Don't confuse "don't want to overthrow the government" with "can't overthrow the government".
Re:"Gun" "Control" by jQueryIsAwesome on Monday December 17, 2012 @04:28PM (#4934488)
You see; the amount of surveillance and military resources exponentially exceeds the ones from the countries you are talking about.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Monday December 17, 2012 @05:30PM (#4934827)
So does the amount of resources available to potential rebels.

And you're making a classic mistake here. Revolutions don't succeed in the face of unified military opposition. In any country. The scenario in a successful US revolution would be a schism or complete mutiny of the armed forces.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by jQueryIsAwesome on Monday December 17, 2012 @07:27PM (#4935390)
I did mention that; anyway; nobody is asking to ban weapons for the military so what is your point?
Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Monday December 17, 2012 @10:35PM (#4935914)
With an armed citizenry you need less of the military on your side.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by jQueryIsAwesome on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @01:29AM (#4936316)
You are very naive; take a look around, unless somehow most Americans stop being fat slow ignorant arrogant elitist self-rightous fools you have a pretty incompetent guerrilla; wish most likely would use the guns just to kill other citizens who disagree with the revolution and many would die because those have guns too. The 2nd amendment was wrote in a time were the enemy was an external entity (Britain), now it would be pointless and more nasty... well, actually it already is.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @04:33AM (#4936743)
I have to chuckle when you, of all people, call me naive. I can only think your opinion of Americans is formed solely by watching television, as you have no idea what you're talking about.

Well, I don't expect someone to understand when he lives in a country full of drug traffickers and communists. Probably gun control is the right thing for you.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by jQueryIsAwesome on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @06:56AM (#4937114)
If you were still interested in having a fruitful conversation you could had ask what data do I have to confirm Americas wouldn't make successful revolutionaries; or at least you would try to explain me why citizens against and pro-government would't kill each other. But instead you decided to call me names.

Let me give you a history lesson; the people you call "drug traffickers" were actually formed as guerrilla and is still called a guerrilla today (FARC and ELN groups); to start a revolution against the government, unfortunately it didn't go so well so the years flied by and they slowly became a rural mafia that kidnap and kill anyone that gets in their way and had long forgot what their purpose is. Another situation that can happen in any country, including America. So yeah, you are very naive about the possible conclusions of an armed revolution.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @12:26PM (#4938490)
>If you were still interested in having a fruitful conversation you could had ask what data do I have to confirm Americas wouldn't make successful revolutionaries; or at least you would try to explain me why citizens against and pro-government would't kill each other.

As if you could actually know something like that better than I.

>But instead you decided to call me names.

Which was entirely appropriate after your last comment.

And yes, I'm aware of the genesis of drug traffickers in Columbia. Your condescending attempt at a "history lesson" isn't required.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by jQueryIsAwesome on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @06:15PM (#4940208)
>As if you could actually know something like that better than I.

The level of arrogance is too damn high.

And you avoided many points, like civiliant against civilian violence in the scenary of a civil war.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @06:48PM (#4940368)
>The level of arrogance is too damn high.

I don't think I'm being particularly arrogant by pointing out your knowledge of my country is of the primary school variety. Even if you had a more average grasp of US society and politics, you still wouldn't know as much as an American. That's just basic common sense, something which seems to be in short supply on your end.

>And you avoided many points, like civiliant against civilian violence in the scenary of a civil war.

That's not a "point" at all. How does it relate to the discussion?

Re:"Gun" "Control" by jQueryIsAwesome on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @09:24PM (#4940842)
Well; you say that guns are good because if a revolution is needed is better if the citizens have guns; the problem is that in revolutions the civilians who doesn't want it also have guns; so it gets really violent without affecting any "tyrant".
Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Thursday December 20, 2012 @12:32AM (#4946414)
Of course it depends on the circumstances. Typically a tyrant maintains power by buying off a small portion of the total population. It can be as little as 10%. Somebody like Marcos in the Philippines comes to mind.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by rmc on Monday December 17, 2012 @03:53AM (#4931443)
The US has a peculiar attachment to its current constitution and it's founding fathers. There seems to be a semi religious adherence to that one document and those original people, as if the US constitution is the first and only document that can grantee liberty and freedom. Many arguments in the US seem to be around "what did the founding fathers really mean?" The hell what they meant, they were wrong!
Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Monday December 17, 2012 @11:52AM (#4933075)
>The US has a peculiar attachment to its current constitution and it's founding fathers.

We have an attachment to the document because that's the blueprint for our government. A nation of laws and not men. The founding fathers some people are more attached to than others.

Many people (like me) believe if you're going to have a written constitution the meaning of the document is fixed, so you have to use secondary sources to be clear on how it was understood when it was ratified. Thus the arguments about "what did the founding fathers really mean".

>The hell what they meant, they were wrong!

No, they weren't. They understood tyranny, having lived under it. You'd think after the 20th century people would be a little leery of investing too much power in their government, but I guess Santayana was right after all.