News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Monday December 17, 2012 @01:41AM (#4931102)
The odds of dying in one of these mass shooting incidents in the US are infinitesimally small. These incidents are the price of freedom, and I'm sad to hear the Aussies are no longer willing to pay it.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by w1ntermute on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:04AM (#4931177)
Yes, I don't understand why no one will come out and say it - such mass murders are simply the price of the freedom to have guns. If everyone is armed, things aren't going to be better, they're going to be worse, as innocent bystanders will get hurt in shootouts between armed civilians and the evildoer they're trying to take out.

One interesting thing that I read recently is that the extremely high rate of firearm murder in America is largely inflicted by and on impoverished black males living in urban areas. If you eliminate those cases/areas from the picture, things are not all that different in America from Europe. You have a higher chance of getting stabbed by a chav in London than you do of getting shot in suburban America.

Of course, there are occasional mass murder incidents (which make the news). But given that most mass murderers are white and have mental problems, mental healthcare reform would take care of those cases that do occur outside of urban areas.

As for the high rate of firearm homicide in urban/black areas, that has more to do with the endemic problems in contemporary African American culture than anything else, and will require a much more comprehensive social policy to correct.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:05AM (#4931183)
>One interesting thing that I read recently is that the extremely high rate of firearm murder in America is largely inflicted by and on impoverished black males living in urban areas. If you eliminate those cases/areas from the picture, things are not all that different in America from Europe.

You aren't supposed to talk about that.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by kls on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:30AM (#4931262)
While I laughed at the dark irony of your response to the subject after a few moments of reflection it's actually pretty depressing because when you really ponder it, political correctness and agendas are the reason that things like a bunch of little kids in a school being senselessly murdered will never get addressed properly and any laws enacted will only be laws of agendas. People won't let go of their own crap for 2 seconds to actually do something good for someone else.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by flyinRyan on Monday December 17, 2012 @04:58AM (#4931645)
>such mass murders are simply the price of the freedom to have guns.

This is absolutely not true. There are plenty of places with standing armies (i.e. pretty much all eligible males have guns in their homes) and don't have anything remotely like the gun murder rate of the US.

Micheal Moore made "Bowling for Columbine" to prove that the reason for the violence was guns themselves. By the end of the his movie, he didn't seem to believe it anymore himself.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by w1ntermute on Monday December 17, 2012 @10:13AM (#4932547)
> This is absolutely not true. There are plenty of places with standing armies (i.e. pretty much all eligible males have guns in their homes) and don't have anything remotely like the gun murder rate of the US.

As I noted in my comment and you apparently failed to understand, mass murders (primarily committed by mentally unbalanced white males) are statistically insignificant compared to the murders committed by and on young poor black urban males on a daily basis. The countries you're comparing the US to here, like Israel and Switzerland, do not have that self-destructive and violent subculture. That is why the US has more firearm homicides per capita than both countries with high rates of gun ownership (like Israel and Switzerland) and those with strict gun controls (like Japan and England).

Neither stricter gun control laws nor looser gun control laws will do much to move the needle on the US statistics because the bulk of murders are committed by and on individuals in a community that systematically ignores the law in the first place. Solving that problem will require a comprehensive social policy that will dismantle large aspects of contemporary African American culture. Unfortunately, it seems that any such suggestions would be political suicide, and therefore are avoided by all politicians.

Eliminating mass murders (which, while currently statistically insignificant, should still be targeted), OTOH, would best be accomplished by providing comprehensive and free asylum-based care to the basket cases that commit such atrocities. Parents should not be allowed to overrule the judgment of medical professionals in such situations.

Of course, none of this changes the fact that eliminating the sales of guns without background checks (such as at gun shows) needs to end right now, as it is a no-brainer.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by flyinRyan on Monday December 17, 2012 @12:44PM (#4933328)
>Neither stricter gun control laws nor looser gun control laws will do much to move the needle on the US statistics because the bulk of murders are committed by and on individuals in a community that systematically ignores the law in the first place.

Exactly, so why were you arguing that gun control is the solution?

>Of course, none of this changes the fact that eliminating the sales of guns without background checks (such as at gun shows) needs to end right now, as it is a no-brainer.

Where in the US can you buy a gun without a background check? I've been away for a while but I was under the impression that this was the norm if you bought from a store (obviously not enforced in private sales, but then the seller better hope the buyer doesn't kill anyone).

Re:"Gun" "Control" by w1ntermute on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:23PM (#4933851)
> Exactly, so why were you arguing that gun control is the solution?

Because preventing ex-felons and mentally deranged people from buying guns (well, anyone who hasn't had a background check done) is an effective form of gun control.

> Where in the US can you buy a gun without a background check?

40% of gun sales occur at gun shows, where no background checks are performed.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Monday December 17, 2012 @03:35PM (#4934197)
As a matter of federal law background checks are not required in sales between private parties. I'm not sure how you would implement a background check system that allows for private party sales while at the same time prevents people from fishing the database for dirt on their neighbors.

Of course there are some states, like California, that don't allow sales between private parties.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by Gormo on Monday December 17, 2012 @09:16PM (#4935707)
> > Exactly, so why were you arguing that gun control is the solution?

> Because preventing ex-felons and mentally deranged people from buying guns (well, anyone who hasn't had a background check done) is an effective form of gun control.

"Concrete isn't edible."

"I know, but limestome-based concrete is the most nutritious kind."

Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Monday December 17, 2012 @05:39PM (#4934877)
>This is absolutely not true. There are plenty of places with standing armies (i.e. pretty much all eligible males have guns in their homes) and don't have anything remotely like the gun murder rate of the US.

You're confusing standing armies and militias/reserves. A standing army is a group of people who are in the army as an occupation.

You are right that the prevalence of gun ownership isn't the whole story. Certainly part of it is cultural. But for now, in this time and in the current state of the US, these incidents really are the price we pay for freedom.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by flyinRyan on Wednesday December 19, 2012 @05:28AM (#4941981)
> A standing army is a group of people who are in the army as an occupation.

It's not the occupation. They're normal citizens that periodically do military training and are expected to be ready at all times should an attack happen. That means having weapons and ammo at home.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by rooshdi on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:17AM (#4931226)
Culture is a not an excuse for allowing humans to gun down each other. Improved firearm regulation can be a part of a comprehensive social policy.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by w1ntermute on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:20AM (#4931233)
I don't disagree with that. However, I don't think that anything will change with stricter gun laws - the people committing all those firearm homicides are the same career criminals who make a living by selling illegal drugs that are smuggled into the country. Do you really think that making guns illegal will change anything for them? In fact, guns are already illegal in many of the urban areas where they live, and that has had no effect at all.

There's no need to punish law-abiding Americans who responsibly own and use firearms under existing laws while maintaining a firearm homicide rate that is similar to that in Europe.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by rooshdi on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:41AM (#4931293)
Those who are law-abiding and have no history of mental illness shouldn't be affected. Data shows about 40% of firearm sales require no background check. [1] Between 1994 and 2008 data also showed that background checks obstructed firearm sales to 1.8 million prohibited people. [2] There is room to improve.

[1] Philip J. Cook & Jens Ludwig, Guns in America: National Survey on Private Ownership and Use of Firearms, U.S. Department of Justice, National Institute of Justice Research in Brief 6-7 (May 1997).

[2] Bureau of Justice Statistics, U.S. Department of Justice, Background Checks for Firearm Transfers, 2008 – Statistical Tables.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by w1ntermute on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:49AM (#4931307)
I don't object to eliminating the sales of guns without background checks. I also believe that children such as the one in this story[0] should be institutionalized (at the state's expense, if need be), so they can be cared for by professionals and not allowed to hurt other people.

I do object to blanket bans of semi-automatic assault weapons, however, or the restriction of concealed carry permits.

0: http://anarchistsoccermom.blogspot.com/2012/12/thinking-unth...

Re:"Gun" "Control" by richcollins on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:24AM (#4931244)
Re:"Gun" "Control" by rmc on Monday December 17, 2012 @04:31AM (#4931552)
If you eliminate those cases/areas from the picture, things are not all that different in America from Europe

That's a dishonest and misleading comparison. You're taking 2 regions (USA & Western Europe) and then removing unhelpful numbers from the USA side and comparing it with W. Europe.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by w1ntermute on Monday December 17, 2012 @10:04AM (#4932506)
Wrong, it's not dishonest or misleading at all. What is dishonest is ignoring the fact that Europe lacks a self-destructive and violent subculture that is disproportionately responsible for firearm homicides in the US when comparing rates of firearm homicides in the US and Europe. It would be like blaming Europe's nomad problem on their social laws while ignoring the fact that there's a huge gypsy community that simply refuses to integrate into society.

By ignoring this fact, you pin the problem on the presence of guns when in fact there's a much deeper problem in society that, if solved, would bring firearm homicides down to the levels in Europe without banning any more types of guns. It also ignores the fact that banning guns would do nothing to stop those who are committing most of the firearm homicides from obtaining guns, since those people are already in the very business of smuggling in another illicit object into the country.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Monday December 17, 2012 @05:48PM (#4934935)
>What is dishonest is ignoring the fact that Europe lacks a self-destructive and violent subculture...

This is certainly not true. The incidence of violent crime in the UK is far higher than in the US. It's just the murder rate in the US is higher.

http://ace.mu.nu/Windows-Live-Writer/Overnight-_D7F6/The-mos...

The rate in the US is 470, which puts us below the bottom of the list. That dichotomy probably does have something to do with guns - breaking and entering is far more dangerous in the US than it is in the UK.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by rmc on Monday December 17, 2012 @01:31PM (#4933552)
ignoring the fact that Europe lacks a self-destructive and violent subculture

If you think Europe lacks violence, I suggest you read a 20th century history book. For example, there have been organised, government promoted genocides in Europe after the Linux kernel was first released.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by w1ntermute on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:17PM (#4933815)
> If you think Europe lacks violence, I suggest you read a 20th century history book.

You speak in the present tense ("lackS"), yet you refer to the 20th century, which ended more than a decade ago. I think you are more than a little confused.

> For example, there have been organised, government promoted genocides in Europe after the Linux kernel was first released.

Please name one country in Western or Northern Europe that has had a "government promoted genocide" since the beginning of the 21st century.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by rmc on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @05:54AM (#4936968)
We are just at the start of the 21st century, so events from the mid to late 20th century are still relevant and culturally important. Why is 10 years suddenly the distant past?

The specific genocide I was talking about was the Bosnian Genocide in the 90s http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bosnian_Genocide

Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Monday December 17, 2012 @03:38PM (#4934211)
>That's a dishonest and misleading comparison.

It is and it isn't when you're talking about policy prescriptions. I don't see why my ability to own a firearm should be restricted because people in other demographics can't use them responsibly.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by richcollins on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:24AM (#4931243)
Re:"Gun" "Control" by rooshdi on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:07AM (#4931193)
America now has about a 9 times higher firearm-related death rate than Australia. [1]

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_firearm-re...

Re:"Gun" "Control" by w1ntermute on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:10AM (#4931209)
This statistic is deceptive. Read my reply above: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4931177
Re:"Gun" "Control" by rooshdi on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:28AM (#4931259)
I've read it. It doesn't change the data.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by w1ntermute on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:30AM (#4931264)
It changes the interpretation of the data, without which the data means nothing.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by rooshdi on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:44AM (#4931297)
What is your interpretation? That some people are irrelevant?
Re:"Gun" "Control" by w1ntermute on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:52AM (#4931311)
Stop putting words in my mouth, I never suggested that anyone is "irrelevant". My interpretation, which should have been obvious, is that you cannot legislate away cultural problems. Banning guns to stop people from obtaining them is completely moronic when those people are in the very business of smuggling of illegal items into the country in the first place.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by rooshdi on Monday December 17, 2012 @03:12AM (#4931358)
There is a difference between banning guns and improving the background check process to ensure less mentally instable and people with a history of crime acquire firearms. Also, it is my opinion that a culture of crime is no excuse to give up on improving firearms regulation.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by w1ntermute on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:20PM (#4933836)
> There is a difference between banning guns and improving the background check process to ensure less mentally instable and people with a history of crime acquire firearms.

I'm not suggesting that we not implement an improved background check process. I'm suggesting that we not start banning semi-automatic assault weapons all of a sudden in order to win some political points over the recent spate of shootings.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by rooshdi on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @02:25AM (#4936464)
I respect your opinion and am actually opposed to the banning of any firearms to those who are qualified and have passed mental and criminal examinations. Currently, about 40% of firearm purchasers are not examined and I believe this number is too high. I appreciate the dialogue, as I believe we need more discussions on this topic.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by angersock on Monday December 17, 2012 @12:31PM (#4933266)
The current nastiness is due directly to the theft of the weapons from a qualified gun owner. Should we extend background checks to include members of the family? Crazy friends? Bad neighbors?
Re:"Gun" "Control" by rooshdi on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @02:06AM (#4936402)
Immediate family? Yes. That is where I would draw the line. Better to experiment than not try.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by rmc on Monday December 17, 2012 @04:32AM (#4931555)
That if you fudge the figures on the USA side, then you can make the USA seem safer!
Re:"Gun" "Control" by w1ntermute on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:19PM (#4933829)
Do you really have nothing better to do than set up strawman arguments?
Re:"Gun" "Control" by andrewflnr on Monday December 17, 2012 @01:54AM (#4931141)
I'm generally in favor of freedom, but you can't assume it's always a good, at any cost. If (and I don't really believe this) frequent mass murders were the cost of freedom, we would have to seriously consider whether it was worth it.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:06AM (#4931192)
What do you mean by "frequent"? The US is a country of 312m people.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by andrewflnr on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:35AM (#4931276)
Find any of the recent threads here on the Connecticut shooting. We (in the US) do seem to have a relatively high per-capita mass-murder rate, at least compared to other first-world countries. That wasn't my main point though.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by w1ntermute on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:44AM (#4931296)
> We (in the US) do seem to have a relatively high per-capita mass-murder rate, at least compared to other first-world countries.

That statistic is misleading and ignores the elephant in the room: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4931177

Re:"Gun" "Control" by flyinRyan on Monday December 17, 2012 @04:59AM (#4931650)
It isn't misleading! You're the one being misleading by claiming we need to cook the data to come up with the result you want to have instead of the reality of the situation.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by Gormo on Monday December 17, 2012 @09:10PM (#4935690)
He isn't "cooking the data". Or, more accurately, he's the one who isn't cooking the all of the data in one big pot, without regard for whether all of the data are actually describing the same thing.

The point he's making is that there are qualitative distinctions within the data that demand their own discrete analysis. What's misleading here is ignoring distinctions in the data in order to falsely posit a uniform source of causality.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by w1ntermute on Monday December 17, 2012 @10:44AM (#4932693)
I'm not suggesting we "cook the data", I'm suggesting that we shouldn't boil the data down to one statistic just so that we can get a number that conveniently agrees with our worldview. See my comment here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4932547
Re:"Gun" "Control" by flyinRyan on Monday December 17, 2012 @12:39PM (#4933309)
>I'm suggesting that we shouldn't boil the data down to one statistic just so that we can get a number that conveniently agrees with our worldview.

Ironically, this is exactly what you're suggesting. Word for word.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by w1ntermute on Monday December 17, 2012 @02:15PM (#4933805)
Wrong again. That's what you are doing. You're taking the number of firearm homicides per capita in the US (one number) and just comparing it to that in other countries.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Monday December 17, 2012 @01:04PM (#4933443)
It's still not what I would call "frequent". Our murder rate has gone down in recent years and isn't high enough to justify new restrictions on firearms, IMO.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by andrewflnr on Monday December 17, 2012 @03:00PM (#4934042)
I don't really disagre with you on gun control, but... You're still hammering on that one word of my original comment. Since you've said nothing against my real point, that the end (that is freedom) doesn't necessarily justify the means, can I assume I've gotten it across? We need to actually think about if and how access to guns improves people's lives overall.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Monday December 17, 2012 @10:48PM (#4935957)
Let me put it this way, then: I don't believe these kinds of incidents are at all common enough to make any changes to American gun laws. Your chance of getting caught up in one is statistically zero, so if people want a gun to hunt or for self defense it outweighs any safety benefit of tighter gun laws.
Re:"Gun" "Control" by rmc on Monday December 17, 2012 @04:29AM (#4931548)
I live in a country with gun control laws. Despite what you may think, this is not a totalitarial oppressive regime. I'm willing to give up my right to bear arms (and my right to pollute the air, etc.)
Re:"Gun" "Control" by tsotha on Monday December 17, 2012 @05:35PM (#4934851)
>I live in a country with gun control laws. Despite what you may think, this is not a totalitarial oppressive regime.

That may be so, but things change. If it becomes a "totalitarial" oppressive regime your options will be more limited than mine.

Re:"Gun" "Control" by rmc on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @08:30AM (#4937364)
Highly unlikely. I live in a small country (Ireland), without any nuclear forces or advanced military. Even the police force aren't armed (except for a special branch), and they have one helicopter. I stand a much better chance against that than you do against the US armed forces.