I find it particularly amusing that many of the people I hear calling for the legalization of all drugs on the grounds that banning them doesn't work, are the same people calling for the outlawing of all guns.
And, honestly, there is nontrivial difference the ability to consume certain substances and owning instruments made explicitly to kill.
There doesn't seem to be much of an upside for the rest of us.
It's also sort of in the roots of the country, so you could say it's sort of patriotic to own a gun and train yourself in its use, but that is of course not a cold, practical argument.
Note: "Self defense" may have raised eyebrows; in particular, I am referring to people like judges and police officers who handle violent criminals. Typically these people are allowed to carry just about anywhere even off-duty.
Note2: In case you aren't actually aware, shotguns are commonly used for hunting, typically for small game and birds.
Note3: Skeet shooting is an Olympic sport. :)
Everything else you mentioned can, I think, be narrowly compromised on -- for shotguns, we can have single or double-barreled breechloaders only, 20 gauge only. That is plenty lethal, and the freedom to own pump-loading and larger gauges are, I think, acceptable casualties.
I think there really is not a fact-based case for the civilian ownership of the majority of weapons designed and sold in the market. Why does anyone need a Bushmaster or knockoff AK?
As for shotguns, while I'm partial to breech loaders, I imagine pump-loaders would be nice when bird hunting- you have literally seconds to take your shots. 12 gauge is popular for hunting, particularly when using a shotgun as a poor man's deer rifle (buckshot or slugs). Anyway, don't worry about shotguns so much. They aren't used much in crime, and I gather they are pretty survivable at all but very close range.
If you want to save lives, forget shotguns, forget rifles, forget even assault rifles- while mass shootings are big news, from a pure numbers point of view handguns are the biggest nail to pound down. More people in rural California in 2010 were killed with handguns than the count for the Connecticut shooting:
http://oag.ca.gov/sites/all/files/pdfs/publications/Firearms...
It's actually quite an interesting document if we're comparing types of firearms.
I've come to develop the POV that we should focus on ensuring that the gun control laws we already have are made effective. When murderers keep showing up with automatic weaponry (when automatic weaponry is basically outlawed) we should start by figuring out how they are getting automatic weaponry.
I don't know.. maybe I just universally underestimate risk, but the targets of these bans or proposed bans all seem motivated by the irrational fear of tragic edge-cases.
Not saying I can prove any of this, but I think the comparison just doesn't work.
(Aurora and the most recent shooter were both in full body armor)
How can we know if it would save even a single life? How would we even know if it was worth it?
You attempt to simplify far too much. In a country of 300 million, can you say with certainty it would not (for example) cost even a single life?
> Except the lack of guns
The benefit of 3D printing is that at least you have a better chance tracing a home printed weapon than you would an illegally purchased street firearm with no serial number.
> Except smart filesharers already can't be caught
Filesharing is different. Printing a gun from a 3D printer requires materials, materials which can easily be traced back to their purchase point of origin. You could argue said materials could be obtained on the black market as well as the printers, but you have a better chance of tracking a created gun back to a particular type of 3D printer. I'm not saying it would be that reliable, but at least law enforcement agencies would stand a better chance than they currently have. Tracking a gun without a serial is like treasure hunting in the pacific ocean without a map.
The benefit of 3D printing is that at least you have a better chance tracing a home printed weapon than you would an illegally purchased street firearm with no serial number.