> is rather telling evidence that our forebears
> found it to be the most effective way to bring
> children in line
Our forebears also felt that the best was to run a society included things like:- Slavery / Indentured Service as a means of generating wealth.
- Punishing women for sexuality (because all women were temptresses, and a man couldn't be blamed for infidelity, rape, etc).
- Torture against criminals / political prisoners.
- Religious wars.
I don't think that "our forebears did it, so there must be something to it," is a generally effective argument.
Re:Thinking the unthinkable
by ampersandy on Monday December 17, 2012 @12:10AM
(#4930929)
You make a great point. I didn't think of the big picture when I made that claim.
My point is that who is the AAP to say how best to raise children? I seriously doubt the validity of any study that claims to be conclusive on how to raise children, and would make a bet that any research they did was localized to the US. Anecdotally, several of my friends were beaten as children and turned out fine. All this proves is that sometimes physical punishment works and sometimes it doesn't. But the same goes for "establishing a loving relationship with your child;" since you can hardly do that when they're threatening to stab you with a knife.