News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Instagram Testimony Doesn't Add Up by crazygringo on Sunday December 16, 2012 @04:05PM (#4929518)
"...before testifying at a hearing of the California Corporations Department, which sought to determine if Facebook’s acquisition of the photo sharing service was in the best interest of Instagram investors."

Can someone explain why this department is doing that? It wasn't a publicly traded company or anything. I'm assuming that Instagram had a board which included seats to represent the VC's, which would have been involved in the various deals.

Are the VC's behind this, alleging that Kevin Systrom kept board members in the dark about a possible Twitter acquisition? Or are people who invest in the VC's behind this, alleging that the VC's betrayed a kind of fiduciary obligation or something? Is the state of CA an investor in the VC's?

The article seems so short on details.

Re:Instagram Testimony Doesn't Add Up by jerrya on Sunday December 16, 2012 @04:17PM (#4929568)
Facebook was organized as a California company and selling securities in California.

Why would you think the state that creates and formalizes the laws under which a company organizes wouldn't have an interest in how that company sells securities in itself?

There's also this:

http://www.corp.ca.gov/Codes/Laws.asp

1. Corporate Securities Law of 1968 (Corporations Code § 25000 et seq.) requires persons offering or selling securities such as stocks or bonds to qualify (e.g., submit to the Department for review and approval) the proposed securities, and requires licensing and regulation of securities broker-dealers and certain investment advisers, except as specified; prohibits misrepresentations, fraudulent and deceptive acts in the offer and sale of securities; and provides administrative, civil (injunction, ancillary relief and appoint of receiver) and criminal remedies for violations of the law.

2. California Commodity Law of 1990 (Corporations Code § 29500 et seq.) prohibits misrepresentation, fraudulent and deceptive acts in the offer and sale of certain off-exchange commodities, except as specified; and provides administrative, civil (injunctions, ancillary relief and appointment of receiver) and criminal remedies for violations of the law.

...

Re:Instagram Testimony Doesn't Add Up by bcoates on Sunday December 16, 2012 @04:51PM (#4929697)
Near the bottom the article briefly mentions that the regulators were worried about "self-dealing" in the Facebook-Instagram deal, where someone was offered a personal side benefit for making the sale happen.

It's a serious problem in corporate governance in the US, but it's not in the interests of any individual involved, including the victim, to uncover any particular instance of it, because the deal is done and a prosecution would only damage the company they presumably still own.

Re:Instagram Testimony Doesn't Add Up by samstokes on Sunday December 16, 2012 @08:03PM (#4930335)
"Facebook requested the hearing as a way to speed up the approval of its acquisition."

I don't know if that was added to the article later, but it seems to explain. It wouldn't normally be a matter for the state, being a private transaction; but closing the deal is a matter for Instagram's investors (who have to agree to sell their shares for the agreed price), and it sounds like Facebook thought getting the investors' approval would be easier if a state department ruled that it was in their best interests.

Re:Instagram Testimony Doesn't Add Up by aptwebapps on Sunday December 16, 2012 @11:46PM (#4930876)
"Can someone explain why this department is doing that?"

Besides the more general reasons that others have given, the last sentence of the first paragraph is, "Facebook requested the hearing as a way to speed up the approval of its acquisition."

Re:Instagram Testimony Doesn't Add Up by jspthrowaway2 on Sunday December 16, 2012 @04:38PM (#4929648)
If Systrom had an offer from Twitter on the table for an amount close to Facebook's offer, the state might view it as opportune to make Twitter and Facebook compete for the company, increasing the return for the investors (whose interest they are representing). If he ignored the Twitter offer but took the Facebook offer due to some personal gain, the state will have a problem with that if it wasn't disclosed to investors. The article discusses that near the end. The entire purchase was shaky -- remember the bit about Zuckerberg not talking to his board? -- so I suspect this isn't the last we'll hear of regulators poking around.

This regulation, which applies to all corporations everywhere, is there to protect investors from being swindled by executives. Without it, we'd have a very different corporate landscape. I don't know if it'd be better or worse, but it'd be very different.

Re:Instagram Testimony Doesn't Add Up by fleitz on Sunday December 16, 2012 @06:37PM (#4930026)
CEO has more responsibilities than just fiduciary duty, and as well it could easily be argued that a deal for $1 b in Facebook stock would be much better than $1.5 b in Twitter stock because of the general uncertainties of the market when dealing with private companies rather than companies that have undergone the fiscal requirements outlined for public companies. tl;dr: Facebook is stock is liquid, Twitter is not.

Unless there are some serious smoking guns here this case is going nowhere fast, Twitter doesn't really have standing in a fiduciary duty case as they are not a shareholder. Since the vast majority of shareholders have not complained it's a pretty easy argument that the vast majority of shareholders are happy with the performance of Instagram.

To nail Instagram they'll have to prove an anti-trust violation, and/or fraud/perjury. Given the underwriters for Facebook this is highly unlikely.

Re:Instagram Testimony Doesn't Add Up by aneth4 on Sunday December 16, 2012 @05:00PM (#4929735)
Exactly. If there is evidence that Systrom did not act in the best interest of shareholders for personal gain, that would be a severe violation of is fiduciary responsibilities, and that would be the under the jurisdiction of the State of California. That is probably the only reason the state would or should be involved.
Re:Instagram Testimony Doesn't Add Up by kelnos on Sunday December 16, 2012 @07:26PM (#4930221)
If Systrom (and his cofounder) had a controlling interest in Instagram, are they even required to act in the best interests of the other shareholders? That's kind of the point of a controlling interest, no? To break ties when shareholders can't decide what's in the overall best interest of the company/shareholders?
Re:Instagram Testimony Doesn't Add Up by aneth4 on Sunday December 16, 2012 @10:17PM (#4930650)
IANAL, however what the majority of shares vote for is not the same as what is in the best interest of shareholders.

For instance, Zuckerberg controls Facebook. He can not decide to use all Facebook's cash as his own personal bonus. That is because it's a clear violation of his fiduciary responsibilities to minority shareholders.

Minority shareholders have a right not to be screwed, though it is VERY difficult to establish misconduct in private companies.

Re:Instagram Testimony Doesn't Add Up by fleitz on Sunday December 16, 2012 @07:34PM (#4930238)
The CEO may not have a fiduciary duty towards minority shareholders, but the controlling shareholders do, in this case it sounds like they are one and the same.

If you have to break a tie, then you aren't a controlling shareholder. The idea behind controlling shareholding is that as long as you follow your duties to the minority you can install whoever you want (perhaps yourself) on the board, the board can then install whoever they want as CEO (perhaps yourself)

These things get really murky in private companies where the board, controlling interest, and CEO are shared by one individual.

Re:Instagram Testimony Doesn't Add Up by kelnos on Sunday December 16, 2012 @07:43PM (#4930272)
"Breaking ties" was a poor choice of words.

It appears that Systrom and Mike Krieger (the other cofounder) together held a majority stake. Assuming the two of them decided to accept the Facebook deal, then they are indeed acting in the best interests of the majority of shareholders, no?

Why do things get murky when the CEO/board/controlling interest is the same? They started and built the company, and structured their funding deals such that they were able to keep majority control wrt voting rights. If they want to screw over the minority shareholders, I think that's pretty lame, but that should be their prerogative.

Re:Instagram Testimony Doesn't Add Up by _delirium on Sunday December 16, 2012 @07:50PM (#4930294)
> If they want to screw over the minority shareholders, I think that's pretty lame, but that should be their prerogative.

The law doesn't really give you blanket approval to do that, though. There are a lot of legal ways to screw over minority shareholders, but lots that aren't. When you sell part of your company, you agree to be bound by certain responsibilities to those minority owners. If you don't like those aspects of contract law, and want to do whatever you want without obligations to other co-owners, you need to keep 100% ownership.

Re:Instagram Testimony Doesn't Add Up by salvadors on Monday December 17, 2012 @04:37AM (#4931569)
There are public policy reasons why a simple majority shouldn't be able to do whatever they like. It would be much harder to ever raise any investment if it were trivial for a majority to simply take everything for themselves and never pass anything back to the investors.

In such a scenario you end up with a boilerplate contract that any right-thinking investor will insist on, just to protect themselves in such a scenario.

Basically, company law has simply declared that those clauses are there by default.