Lets create a hypothetical example, you are an 'angel' investor and you invest in a company "WunderKund Inc". In exchange for your investment you get 10 or 15% of the company interest, now lets say WunderKund grows rapidly, they really hit a niche, maybe they have a series A, and people start to express an interest in acquisition. The angel investor is perhaps diluted down to 1 - 2% of the preferred stock, and maybe its one of those deals where the founders still have control of the preferred. Now along comes a buddy of one of the founders and says "Hey, awesome how about we make you rich, and you can come to work with me!?" and its awesome and all but there is this other less awesome company saying "Hey we really want to acquire you we'll pay what ever it takes..."
Now as the Angel Investor your interest is getting as good a return as possible on your investment because you know that only 1 out of 100 of your investments will pay off. How do you prevent the founders from making a sweet heart deal ("under market") with their buddy that makes them rich enough, and leaves a bunch of money from the other guys on the table that would have added to your return? If you are making less than full value that is one thing, but what if you're getting completely frozen out because the "sweet heart" company is offering very little cash or stock but big earn out bonuses for the founders if they stay on at BigCorp?
There are lots of ways that you can structure a deal that benefits one party more than the others and this commission was created to mitigate the damage done by unscrupulous business people.
(Found the link: http://www.corp.ca.gov/ENF/FairnessHearings/Default.asp)
Its the California Department of Corporations
This is the result of the Instagram / Facebook hearing : http://www.corp.ca.gov/Press/news/2012/Facebook_08-29-12.pdf
I would be very interested to know what the procedural background here is. (Unfortunately, this hit piece of an article does not go into detail about this).
Quite the contrary. In the United States, states watch dealings like a hawk and legal opinion is that states hold the line on antitrust and other anticompetitive corporate governance issues. Federal invention is seen as supplementary here. California v. ARC America Corp. (1989), at 490 U. S. 102[1]:
> Congress intended the federal antitrust laws to supplement, not displace, state antitrust remedies.
(IANAL, etc.) I'm curious. Why do you consider this article a hit piece?
[1]: http://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/490/93/case.html
This seems to be an investigation as to whether Instagram screwed their investors by taking a low ball offer. And I am curious why the state is investigating this to begin with.
The compliance requirements are effectively a tax on acquisitions. We're only better off with this tax if it prevents more damage than it costs to enforce. The enforcement cost is not just on everyone's time, but it also effectively restricts their available decisions in unanticipated ways (for example wanting to ensure that there's appearance of compliance with the law). It's clearly costing Instagram/Facebook to comply, can anyone point to a case where having this regulation helped/would have helped an investor and therefore was a good thing?
I don't know why, but it seems like there's a pro-bureaucracy mindset on HN. People seem to be supportive of rules as long as there's a coherent reason for them without questioning if the rule is a net negative. Can someone explain this to me?
That'd be a faux pas in this context.
Between two corporations, fine, but to bring in lawyers against Facebook/Instagram in this context would bring a lot of stigma.
Better to let the gov't be your barking dog.
This is most certainly not nonsense if true, though it is a bit ridiculous given the windfall for investors.
If you have ever been a major shareholder in a company, you would understand - not considering legitimate offers for acquisition is a major no-no and violates the most important responsibilities of a the corporate stewards.
By the way, a term sheet is usually first sent over email, as it will be redlined several times before anyone signs it. As the CEO of a startup, a printed term sheet without the corresponding email trail would be very suspect.
Nobody has said there is proof of anything, but the government has grounds for suspicion. That is all. Presumably an investigation is warranted.
Presumably Facebook at that point in time, is a business incorporated by the State of California. I don't know of any national corporation process.
It's not clear to me (and I am certainly not a lawyer) that the protection of investors and the protection of taxpayers at that stage of the company falls to the SEC and not at all to the state regulators of the state that incorporated the company.
As others have pointed out, please remember what an extraordinarily weird thing the modern corporation is. In older conceptions of how to run a business, investors had the right to hold the directors personally liable for losses. Now, we have a system which largely removes that; in exchange for removing that check, others must be instituted, and a higher level of scrutiny (since a person who is not responsible for losses arguably has less incentive to avoid losses) is entirely appropriate. Since this privilege of freedom from liability is a creation of the state government, it is appropriate that the state government is actively involved in the oversight.