Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant
by alwa on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:15PM
(#49274777)
If I, as Joe HOA President, walk up to the deputy and ask whether they wrote down plate ABC-XYZ, the answer would be no. Or at least “why, did they commit a crime”?
If I, as five-states-away-podunk-town-cop, walk up to the sheriff’s deputy and ask if they saw a specific vehicle, the answer would probably depend on the degree of trust between our departments. Which would probably be low if they don’t know me. If I then said “oh, but you should, because it’s my ex, I wanna know if she’s seeing this guy I hate,” the answer would be “no, and get out of here before you buy yourself an investigation into you.”
So one difference in kind is the cross-jurisdictional “sharing” (which extends even to private, non-governmental parties!). There’s a difference between the deputy writing down what they see and a clown car packed with a cop from every department in America plus every Home Depot plus every nosy HOA.
I’d argue “requires an employee to sustain” vs “does not require any meaningful cost to sustain” is also a difference in kind—certainly with respect to the sorts of policies that flow from it.
If I, as five-states-away-podunk-town-cop, walk up to the sheriff’s deputy and ask if they saw a specific vehicle, the answer would probably depend on the degree of trust between our departments. Which would probably be low if they don’t know me. If I then said “oh, but you should, because it’s my ex, I wanna know if she’s seeing this guy I hate,” the answer would be “no, and get out of here before you buy yourself an investigation into you.”
So one difference in kind is the cross-jurisdictional “sharing” (which extends even to private, non-governmental parties!). There’s a difference between the deputy writing down what they see and a clown car packed with a cop from every department in America plus every Home Depot plus every nosy HOA.
I’d argue “requires an employee to sustain” vs “does not require any meaningful cost to sustain” is also a difference in kind—certainly with respect to the sorts of policies that flow from it.