News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Compression Is Prediction by adrianN on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @11:42PM (#49267606)
I'm not aware of a better definition of "understanding" that would allow me to tell whether some system "understands" some other system. Do you happen to know one?
Re:Compression Is Prediction by hnfong on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:45AM (#49268232)
See: A. M. Turing (1950) Computing Machinery and Intelligence. Mind 49: 433-460.

I mean, my interpretation is that the question Turing tried to answer is equivalent to "How can we determine whether machines understand humans/human thought?"

This only works when both systems can talk about pretty much arbitrary things, but if you want a more general method for less complex systems, perhaps having one system simulate another system is sufficient. (Which is also another Turing invention)

Re:Compression Is Prediction by adrianN on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @03:06AM (#49268783)
There are many people who would claim that passing the Turing test is insufficient to show "understanding" (compare for example the Chinese Room thought experiment).
Re:Compression Is Prediction by hnfong on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @05:54AM (#49269932)
Yes but it's (kind of?) a definition as you asked for.

At this point, I am unaware of a better definition. I know the Chinese Room argument (and I disagree with it), but I'm not aware whether the proponents of that argument have a better definition of understanding other than "well, the Turing Test isn't enough"...

---

PS: Interestingly the issue of compression is highly relevant regarding the Chinese Room argument -- the essential element in the Chinese Room argument is that the information is not compressed...