News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by estearum on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @12:34PM (#49260785)
I wouldn't blame her but anyone who has to check out should just fail.

This is about gunning for the elite/upper echelons of society. Doing that requires working like a dog not just for 2 years of high school and 4 years of college, but for likely several decades after.

It's totally fine if not everyone can do it and that more people try than actually achieve it. It would be surprising if those weren't true, and engineering the system otherwise is just degrading what it means to achieve the result.

Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by raddan on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @12:50PM (#49261036)
> This is about gunning for the elite/upper echelons of society.

Is that what it’s about? Keep in that the University of Michigan is a public university, explicitly founded to “provide the inhabitants of this state with the means of acquiring a thorough knowledge of the various branches of literature, science, and the arts.” There’s nothing about being elite in there at all. This is an institution that serves the public.

I’m no stranger to long hours to achieve high status—I’m a professor. But I also started my journey at a public school and a public undergraduate institution. Many of my friends—all good and smart people but in many cases decidedly NOT elite-have leveraged their public education into satisfying careers. I, and my friends, would not have had our opportunities otherwise. I simply could not afford top private school.

I don’t know what to think about this change exactly, but it’s worth pointing out that MIT has had this policy for first year students since 1968. MIT! Seems like UM can make this work if they are thoughtful about it.

Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by estearum on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @01:45PM (#49261830)
All universities are for the elites. I would love for that not to be the case, but the only reason admissions are this competitive is because there's competition for limited slots.

And yes, certainly a (traditional) university education should not be required for having good career opportunities.

IMO there's a need for a type of education that's vastly more scalable and still equips people with the beyond-secondary education they need to be productive in today's economy.

Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by raddan on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @06:19PM (#49265265)
I’m not sure where you get the idea that all universities are competitive because that is simply untrue. Many public universities are required by state legislatures to broadly admit students from their own state. California is a good example. You can see incoming class statistics here: https://www.collegetransitions.com/dataverse/entering-class-...

Competitive universities are competitive. Sometimes that competiton is justified and sometimes it is unjustifiably based on pedigree. The program I attended before getting my PhD at a public university was at a well-known private university. But in terms of research productivity and impact, the public university was a MUCH better place to go to school. The PhD program was exceptionally competitive but its undergrad program was not. As a result, many undergrads who wandered through our lab door got a first-class research experience.

I’m not going to pretend that pedigree doesn’t matter (to some people), but it is emphatically not the same thing as “a good preparation.” I took a couple math classes one summer at a low-tier state college. They were just as good as any math classes I took at any of the other places I went to school, public or private.

Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by estearum on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @07:18PM (#49265798)
The ones that aren't competitive don't have the ultra-competitive dynamics described above. Not sure what your point is.

That still doesn't mean they're not "for the elites." Universities are for people striving for upward mobility, i.e. to get into or maintain membership in the elite tiers of society. Also there is (obviously) significant variation in the upper end of the elite and the lower end.

Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by raddan on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @10:29PM (#49267190)
More than a third of the US population has a college degree. [1] When you consider the fact that 20% of the US population are children [2] that means that roughly half of the eligible US population has a college degree. If “half” is elite, then I’m not sure what “elite” means, because it’s not very exclusive.

> Not sure what your point is.

Well, you said

> All universities are for the elites.

And then I countered that, actually, many are not selective. I am asking you to reconsider your statement. In reality, many college programs confer _skills_, not _status_. This narrative that colleges are for the elites is demonstrably untrue, runs counter to the founding mission of many of them, and strikes me as sour grapes. I know because I was one of the kids who struggled to afford college, went to a public one where I learned _skills_, which I then leveraged into a satisfying career.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Educational_attainment_in_the_...

[2] https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/visualizat...

[dead]
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by neuroticnews25 on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @07:56AM (#49271002)
> All universities are for the elites. I would love for that not to be the case

What would have to change for you to declare it's not the case?

Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by estearum on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @08:13AM (#49271181)
The costs would have to go down significantly. And I don't just mean the direct price to students – even public universities are extremely costly overall.

It costs ~$55k/year to educate a student at UMich. That's more than half of the median US family's income. And UMich is a massive success story. Excellent academic output at a relatively great price – but even there the actual cost would bankrupt a normal American family.

That's a lot of money to spend educating someone into a non-elite trajectory in life, no?

Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by vel0city on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:02AM (#49273500)
Isn't that need of post-secondary education "solved" by community colleges? Extremely cheap for locals, usually offering degree/certification programs especially relevant to employers in the area, extremely lax requirements, etc?
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by estearum on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:40PM (#49275161)
In theory yes, in practice it seems empirically like the answer is no. I'm not sure if it's just a vibes/branding problem or what. But yeah I think much larger and more capable community colleges and smaller universities is probably closer to ideal.
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by InsideOutSanta on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @03:56PM (#49263597)
I don't think training people to burn out by 35 is a good plan for anyone involved.
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by joezydeco on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @12:47PM (#49260985)
Let me tell you about the scam of 'honors' classes in today's high schools. They not doing anything more introspective or challenging. It's the same classwork thrown at them faster and without as much teaching support. Just more to grind out. But when you don't understand something?

You're smart, you'll figure it out.

In return you get inflated GPAs that get you into better colleges. But if you can't figure it out on the first try? More stress.

Interestingly, a lot of colleges now ignore the 'honors' weighted GPA and ask to see the unweighted score. If you have a teen entering high school, skip the honors track and help them do better in the normal track version of the class. See if your school offers dual-credit with a local community college or state university. Those transfer credits are WAY more valuable now (and cheaper!) than an AP score, with a lot less test stress.

Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by estearum on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @01:46PM (#49261849)
Yeah definitely. But "can you grind" is legitimate selection criterion for making it into the upper echelons. Not an ideal one, but it's not illegitimate.
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by Hizonner on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @03:33PM (#49263311)
Legitimate in what way? It's obviously fucking stupid. Stupid criteria are not "legitimate".

You'd do just as well rolling dice, and it would be more legitimate because it wouldn't be pretending to do something it doesn't.

Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @03:58PM (#49263630)
> Legitimate in what way?

Can you teach yourself, broadly. Out of all the filters we have in education, this one might be the most legitimate because it maps pretty closely to lifelong curiosity and learning.

Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @03:58PM (#49263626)
> Legitimate in what way?

Can you teach yourself, broadly. Out of all the filters we have in education, this one might be the most legitimate.

Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by estearum on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @04:31PM (#49264041)
A lot of the jobs that university is supposed to train you for require you to work very very hard for a very very long time.
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by liveoneggs on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @07:52AM (#49270950)
honors classes have better behavior
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by hduto on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @08:05AM (#49271097)
I agree partially with your first point and almost entirely with your 2nd point:

After emerging from an ap/ib honors program in highschool (with excellent teachers) I became increasingly stressed in college when any real simple lack of comprehension occurred. I was smort. I should "get it."

However, later in life the ideas from books or concepts we read, discussed, and critiqued (Doestevsky,Shakespeare, sophocles etc) allowed me access to ideas in the humanities that far outweighed that initial college whiplash. So it's a trade off I would certainly make again.

Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by christoff12 on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @08:21AM (#49271257)
Knowing what I know now, I definitely would've opted for dual-credit rather than honors/AP classes, and CLEPed out of the remainder of freshman year basics.
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by vjulian on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @12:44PM (#49260949)
Working like a dog like this is necessary if you’re gunning for the elite / upper echelon of society, yes. If you’re already in that echelon of society, it’s not necessary.

Thank goodness I didn’t need to work so hard, but I can acknowledge what a shitty system it is.

Help me understand why these children or their parents are gunning in this manner and working like dogs in this manner, to join into and propagate such a shitty system?

Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by estearum on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @01:46PM (#49261854)
Because having money is a lot better than not having money
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by somenameforme on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @10:43AM (#49273162)
I think it's more that if one doesn't really think one way or the other then life is very much a conveyor belt, and that belt will typically push you into college. And if you're going to go to college, why not go to the best that you can?
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by estearum on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:41PM (#49275169)
Universities are still very good investments for most people who go to them
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by somenameforme on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:21PM (#49275787)
In the US the overwhelming majority of people aren't majoring in STEM, and the return for most non-STEM majors is likely negative relative to something like a trade. Even for traditionally well paid cognitive work, LLMs are making the future quite murky. Weird and interesting times we live in. Who knows, maybe the future will make fine arts great again? Personally, I won't be discouraging or encouraging my children to go to college. I'll explain the pros and cons in both directions and leave it up to them.
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by uncivilized on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @01:24PM (#49261526)
Sad state that of affairs when comments like this appear and have affirmative replies. Shows how socially unaware and one-dimensional a Hacker News is.
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by estearum on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @01:49PM (#49261890)
Competition continues to rise for limited higher education slots. The solution is not to get rid of the measurements we use to decide who should occupy those slots, it's to add more slots (and ideally, also create viable career/life opportunities that do not require a super-expensive education to begin with).

Can you explain how that's "socially unaware" or "one-dimensional"?

Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by uncivilized on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:31PM (#49275029)
Well your comment had nothing to do with what you’ve written now.

There’s a reason why it’s flagged now.

Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by estearum on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:42PM (#49275182)
It's flagged because there are crybabies in this thread lol
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by consensus1 on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @12:44PM (#49260953)
Do we really want the upper echelons of society to be made up of neurotic workaholics? Do we really want universities to be gate keepers here at all?
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by hackyhacky on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @12:49PM (#49261024)
No, we don't, but the alternatives are worse.

Universities at least apply some meritocratic standards. If we bypass universities, there will be some other gatekeeper, it will be worse: mostly an "old boys network" and corrupt, pay-to-play advancement.

Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by consensus1 on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @07:20PM (#49265824)
Seems like the country was more competently governed before the current university system, though. If its job is to gate keep incompetence out of leadership it is failing spectacularly.
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by hackyhacky on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @07:54PM (#49266104)
> before the current university system,

When was that? Harvard was founded in 1636.

Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by estearum on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @07:39PM (#49265978)
When you consider the complexification of any single industry over the last 50 to 100 years, then multiply that by every single other industry, then multiply that by the newly complex interactions between industries, then consider that the government must keep some degree of handle on all of that complexity, and consider that they must do it with a smaller headcount per capita (even before Trump) than ever before, against better-funded and more sophisticated "adversaries" (people/orgs trying to evade government management) than ever before ...

It seems very possible to me that the managers of said system are far better than ever before and still fail to produce spectacular results.

Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by mishellaneous on Thursday August 13, 2026 @07:14AM (#49284300)
where i come from, university admissions are determined exclusively by performance on an exam you take after high school. it's meritocratic, and the work it involves is much more sensible IMO: no leadership/well-roundedness/whatever theater, and in the ideal case, it only lasts 1 year.

also, this grind is barely meritocratic. all these extracurricular activities show is you had a solid family supporting you. it's literally impossible for a poor kid to participate in this. they can pick up a book, OTOH. yes, it'll be harder, it'll take longer, and they won't do as well as the rich kids with test prep, but they are given the opportunity to try.

Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by throwitaway222 on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @12:50PM (#49261044)
We want no more universities, as it's just producing socialists unless you're in math / sciences, and if you're in the sciences it's wasting productive time in industry.
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by estearum on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @01:47PM (#49261870)
Surely if it was wasting productive time in industry, then companies would just hire people directly out of high school, no? There's a reason they don't do that.
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by shibapuppie on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @05:46PM (#49264930)
Oh no, socialism.
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by buellerbueller on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @09:15AM (#49271926)
I, personally, want more socialists. I think it would be a good thing for people to bear a bit more responsibility to one another in the USA.
Re:University of Michigan Drops First-Semester Grades To'Cur... by porridgeraisin on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @04:53PM (#49264325)
I'm all for not diluting anything but dropping first semester/year grades is unlikely to cause any major issue IMO. You can encourage lighter electives maybe and remove some elective requirements from later in the course. Already first year courses are fairly generic/light anyways. The purpose is simply to ramp up the competitiveness the same way school itself ramps up over the years. Pretending school momentum carries over to college is just stupid.