And to be honest, this sort of compiler-specific ABI interoperability is a non-problem that doesn't need solving, it's at most relevant for software developers of closed source libraries who distribute the libraries as precompiled blobs. But those must be stamped out for different target-triples anyway.
Ultimately any ABI discussions need to happen between CPU and OS vendors, compiler toolchains implement whatever comes out of those discussions.
idk, given how ABI impacts the evolution of C I think it's not unreasonable to provide a mechanism by which ABI can be evolved even if it's not specifically for compiler interop.
> Ultimately any ABI discussions need to happen between CPU and OS vendors, compiler toolchains implement whatever comes out of those discussions.
I think part of the article author's reasoning for proposing this feature is that toolchains have implemented something like this feature to try to address ABI issues and that the rest of the ecosystem could benefit from a similar technique.
For areas like application plugins via DLLs it's the OS ABI that matters.
I don't get quite the same impression. The sense I get is more that such a change would basically need to happen "bottom-up":
> Some of [the scenarios that aren't fixed by this proposal] are just the normal dependency management issues. If you build a library on top of something else that uses one of the changed types (such as intmax_t or something else), then you can’t really upgrade until your dependents do.
> <snip>
> For those of us in large ecosystems who have to write plugins or play nice with other applications and system libraries, we’re generally the last to get the benefits.
In which case the benefit of the proposal (as far as I understand) is that such bottom-up changes can occur without forcibly breaking other consumers.