News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How not to turn ideologically crazy by antisthenes on Sunday August 09, 2026 @09:41PM (#49238293)
I am with the author on how people get radicalized, but he could not have picked a worse example that Marxism as an example of extremist idea.

Equating Marxism to labor theory of value is akin to maybe equating economics to a supply/demand curve.

There are unequivocally true parts of Marxism, such as surplus value of labor, and the fundamental incentive conflict between a capital owner and laborer (which Marx deems exploitation)

The labor theory of value is also I think misinterpreted by modern economists as a price-setting mechanism, which it isn't. It's a mechanism to show that there is a certain floor on value of an economic good, which is raised every time constructive labor is applied to a product.

Re:How not to turn ideologically crazy by zahlman on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @02:01AM (#49268369)
> It's a mechanism to show that there is a certain floor on value of an economic good, which is raised every time constructive labor is applied to a product.

The problem is that this argument is circular: whether the labor is "constructive" gets judged by whether it succeeded in adding value.