News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by unethical_ban on Sunday August 09, 2026 @10:28AM (#49231756)
Why people oppose datacenters:

Philosophical opposition to AI's impact on society.

Resource utilization: power and water.

Pollution: natural gas turbines on site and broadly the pollution of power generation, and noise pollution.

Subsidies to multitrillion dollar companies at the expense of taxpayers.

Impact on local community: traffic, construction, impact to surrounding home prices.

Lies about the benefits of datacenters: talk of how much money it might bring governments, while no dividends are paid to citizens impacted by the negative effects above.

---

If a datacenter was quiet, powered by renewables, water-efficient in a place without water supply insecurity, and funded by the builders instead of taxpayers, most complaints would be solved.

These operators are in such a rush to build that they are ignoring all decency and resident concern in many cases.

Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by dlubarov on Sunday August 09, 2026 @11:47AM (#49232492)
> Philosophical opposition to AI's impact on society.

I think this is the real reason, while the others don't make that much sense when we really think about it.

Large datacenters are normally limited to industrial zoned land, so they're "competing" for space with other industrial projects, and their externalities are typically mild compared to other industrial projects.

Most datacenters create little traffic, minimal pollution, and no bad odors. They do use substantial power and water, but they pay for it (though in certain cases the economics aren't perfect).

I'd much rather live near a datacenter than a dump, sewage facility, refinery, etc. etc.

Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by gruez on Sunday August 09, 2026 @11:48AM (#49232510)
>Subsidies to multitrillion dollar companies at the expense of taxpayers.

How does this square with the fact that one county in Virginia derives half of its budget from datacenters?

Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by xtiansimon on Sunday August 09, 2026 @11:59AM (#49232609)
Half of a dollar is fifty-cents. A lot of work is necessary to put that figure into the framing of the benefits of data centers for communities.
Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by gruez on Sunday August 09, 2026 @12:00PM (#49232624)
"subsidies" implies the number is negative. Now it sounds like you're moving the goalposts from "datacenters are getting subsidized" to something vague like "they're not paying enough".
Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by unethical_ban on Sunday August 09, 2026 @09:23PM (#49238190)
Well, if it happened in one place, it must be happening everywhere.
Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by xtiansimon on Friday August 14, 2026 @02:05PM (#49302434)
> “These operators are in such a rush to build…”

And take advantage of old laws never written to address the industry.