News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ole Roemer and the Speed of Light by jacquesm on Friday December 14, 2012 @03:20AM (#4920059)
Without a measurement to go with it and without any reason to name one or another number this looks like so much tweaking to work backwards from an answer already known.

All the answers to the worlds questions are in the Qur'an, the Bible and any other manner of ancient texts, if you want to believe that. Pi = 3 right? And what's a cubit?

The problem is that without a procedure to arrive at the 2202 there is little value in this. This is the number that needs an explanation, without a description of an experiment it could be the truth, it could be a lucky guess, or maybe someone thought that if they tweaked the meaning of the various elements in the explanation by a bit here and there they could make it fit the required answer.

There is enough leeway in there that I really don't think this should go with the header you've given it.

What is an interesting question is how the 2202 was arrived at, how much leeway there was for each of the ancient units given and what that implies for the error bars of the answer. That might yield some valuable insight.

There are no comments on this comment yet.