News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by WalterBright on Monday August 03, 2026 @11:46PM (#49164183)
From your reference: "it is the colonizers who get to write the history"

There's a simple explanation for this. The colonists were literate, and would keep diaries and write letters about their experiences. Churches would log births, deaths, and marriages. Printers would print newspapers. Later, these materials were fodder for academics who converted them into historical narratives.

The Indians were not literate and so did not write letters and keep diaries.

Even things like the number of Indians cannot be pinned down with any precision.

Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by paimapi on Monday August 03, 2026 @11:59PM (#49164232)
the Native Americans were highly literate, they just didn't record granular details to ledgers because they didn't have strictly hierarchical institutions that utilized this data for controlling their population

there is so much easily searchable resources for this and though it might not be your intent, your comment reads as willfully ignorant for being so broad and bought into the type of 16th century Puritan Eurocentrism that many of the articles above discuss in depth

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mesoamerican_writing_systems * https://www.science.org/content/article/roots-mesoamerican-w... * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ojibwe_writing_systems * https://www.britannica.com/topic/Indigenous-languages-of-Nor...

Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by WalterBright on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @12:19AM (#49164323)
Highly literate? From your britannica reference:

"No native writing system was known among Indigenous peoples of North America at the time of first European contact"

And yes, I was referring to the North American Indians. I know the Mayans had writing. I even have a book on the Mayan writing system.

> they didn't have strictly hierarchical institutions that utilized this data for controlling their population

People did not write letters and keep diaries in order to control their population.

The book "Empire of the Summer Moon" which is a history of the Commanche empire, and the book laments that their only sources were diaries and letters written by colonists.

Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by curioadu on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @03:48AM (#49165526)
I wonder if one could group Central American and North-Central-American civilizations and peoples into two gross and very approximate groups:

1: Sedentary farmers like Aztecs and possibly Pueblos and those doing Three Sisters farming, some of them like the Aztecs having significant civilizational achievements all considered.

2: Hunting nomads, first doing fire-stick farming to create good conditions for hunting animals as well as gather certain plants, and later utilizing horses after their introduction from Europe.

Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by Gangway0829 on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @12:02AM (#49164255)
If 90+% of whatever society you are from was killed off by disease, and the people who came across the survivors treated them as little better than cattle and systematically destroyed any remaining trace of your society, how literate would history judge you to be?
Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by WalterBright on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @12:30AM (#49164375)
See my quote from the Britannica.
Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by parineum on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @01:13AM (#49164563)
Literate has a definition that requires the ability to read and write. The North American native population was, by definition, illiterate. They had no written word.

It doesn't mean they were stupid, they obviously picked it up quickly when they were exposed to it

Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by culi on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @01:39AM (#49164671)
I don't think that's true. Mesoamerica had a very rich tradition of papermaking (Amatl) that predated paper in Europe (though probably not Chinese). Colonists severely repressed, criminalized, and even destroyed the paper and writing systems. Thousands of Maya codices were burned in 1562. Almost all pre-colombian libraries (amoxcalli) were destroyed

We've deciphered Nahuatl and Maya script but Zapotec, Olmec, Isthmian, Quipu, and other scripts are still not well understood

Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by curioadu on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @03:38AM (#49165458)
The destruction during the Spanish conquests of the Aztecs and others was terrible. It was also rather disorganized initially, especially due to the huge delays regarding communication between the Americas and Europe.

In regards to paper, while the Aztecs had impressive achievements, especially considering the almost complete isolation of the Americas from the rest of the world (is there any civilization close to the achievements of the Aztecs and other Amerindians in Africa south of Egypt?), are you sure that amatl/amate counts as paper? It was possibly stretched bark, and not woven.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amate#True_paper

> The Maya used a writing material called huun starting from the 5th century. It was made from the inner bark of the wild fig tree. It was cut and stretched thin rather than made of randomly woven fibers, which according to one source, disqualified it as true paper.

Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by graemep on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:40AM (#49166258)
> is there any civilization close to the achievements of the Aztecs and other Amerindians in Africa south of Egypt?

Aksum for a start.

Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by curioadu on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @07:25AM (#49167055)
Aksum was more east of Egypt than south, right? And part of it lay in the Arabian Peninsula.
Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by graemep on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @09:39AM (#49168845)
More south than east.

It conquered part of the Arabian peninsula.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aksumite_Empire

Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by desotus on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @06:56PM (#49176418)
It more or less bordered or was really close to Egypt, and it was on the very coastal edge of the African continent, as close as is possible to the Arabian Peninsula, and even conquered territory outside Africa. And if the conquered parts are included, it was somewhat east as well at the very least. Did it only conquer in that direction? There are the Adwa mountains (and even the active stratovolcano Adwa), somewhat separating Axum from its south-western direction further into Africa. The capital Axum was at a very high elevation in the highlands, like more than 2000 meters above sea level, and relatively close to the other major cities. Deserts might also have separated stretches of the empire to its west. It also must have had a lot of foreign influence, as per the Greek writing on some of its coins. And the capital Axum itself was relatively close to the coast. And one description I found just mentioned coastal or near-coastal Axum cities, not cities much further inland. Adulis was coastal, and Matara like Axum was not far from the coast. I do not know if it had any other cities. One source mentions Ptolemais Theron as a coastal city. And then some writers describe the Aksum empire as highly cosmopolitan, like Adulis having a large Greek population.

If it had partial natural borders like deserts, mountains and an active volcano, somewhat separating it from the rest of Africa in its south-western and western direction, and sizable numbers of Greeks and other peoples, and located on the very edge of Africa as close as possible to the Arabian Peninsula, it doesn't really seem to me to be the best example, upon closer examination. I can sort of understand why you would mention it as an example, though

Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by graemep on Wednesday August 05, 2026 @04:41AM (#49180156)
You have created a new account just to repeat downvoted or dead comments made by your other account?
Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by jcranmer on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @09:33AM (#49168778)
> is there any civilization close to the achievements of the Aztecs and other Amerindians in Africa south of Egypt?

Mali? Great Zimbabwe?

Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by desotus on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @06:54PM (#49176397)
The Mali Empire was not far south of Egypt, it overlapped with the Sahara and was relatively late, 1235-1610, and is primarily known for its rich natural resources, namely gold, which cannot be said to be an achievement. It was significantly large and did last for centuries, at least. It had lots of contact with others, such as regarding the empire more or less adhering to Islam. There are some mosques there, but some of them are adobe buildings, and some of them were reconstructed in the 1900s. Apart from gold, which is not an achievement, what achievements did the Mali empire have that comes close to that of the Aztecs and other Amerindians? Manding languages did not have their own script as far as I can tell, only Arabic and Latin.

.

Great Zimbabwe's Great Enclosure is something, but it seems much less impressive than that of for instance Chichen Itza, despite being younger. And Great Zimbabwe must have had international trade, given artifacts from China was found there. On the other hand, archeologists and Europeans accidentally damaged it, and time wore it down, and thus it might have been more impressive than the current ruins indicate. The building approach with small, mortarless stones, and wooden lintel instead of arches or huge stones, despite the time period being 1100s to 1500s, might have limited what could be constructed, but perhaps the original edifices employed other techniques as well than wooden lintel. Though I do not understand how the wooden lintel survived that many centuries. Dry climate?

Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by WalterBright on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @01:56AM (#49164761)
Sorry, I was talking about North America.
Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by culi on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @02:02AM (#49164795)
The epicentre of Amatl was North America (Mexico)
Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by WalterBright on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @11:51AM (#49170643)
Mexico is considered central America.
Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by culi on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @01:41PM (#49172220)
Re:Amazonian civilization had estimated 3M people in 3% of f... by WalterBright on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:18PM (#49175305)
The Britannica sez:

"No native writing system was known among Indigenous peoples of North America at the time of first European contact"