The second one is also Anthropic, same model even.
you are seeing single realizations of non-deterministic processes. Confidently stating one model is better than the other is not really possible this way; that's just like stating one dice is better than the other because you rolled a six with that one on the first try.
In either case, I still don't see how I could reproduce this to test against various models, which is the entire point of Simon's pelican.