there is also nothing selectively about it, it applies to all deep fake equally
if you had read the article you would know that this is mainly about deep fakes and other deceptive content, not every use of an AI tool (e.g. line smoothing) requires an AI label, specifically it's only about content "generative AI" usage _in a context where it's potentially deceptive_.
> AI commissars who will decide which company will survive
a huge jump in logic not related to anything in this article
> I doubt EU will survive the next decade or two without major crisis or war tbh.
again unrelated, but any country which doesn't fights deep fake propaganda will most likely not survive as a democratic state of law, soo if anything this action increases the chance of survival
> Edit: Instead of downvoting, how about you try retorting?
- then maybe read the article properly, your comments put it highly in question you did
- also maybe don't have non logically sustained jumps in reasoning in your article, especially not when you jumps in reasoning come with tons of sarcasm
> I don't think I'm incorrect here. But maybe I am!
well yes, you have even missed the long known, explicitly pointed out sever threat deep fake propaganda is for any state and especially democracies. That is not a good bases for any argument.
Also passive aggressive edits are a good way to get even more down votes if anything.
Content label doesn't transform the content. It just provides a false sense of category.
I still have to think critically whether there is a label or not.
Cons: New ways for sociopaths for corruption, embezzlement and censorship.
That is my point.
This idea that legislation has no downsides is extremely naive and borderline retarded. Look at proposed legislation from the point of someone who wants to destroy everything. Does it provide a path to that goal? Is the risk worth it?
Every government grows over time and produces more and more suffering while consuming more and more wealth. I recommend reading The Gulag Archipelago. Your thinking seems to be dangerously naive to you and people around you.
> Cons: New ways for sociopaths for corruption, embezzlement and censorship.
bot points are just plain wrong, to a point where I'm wondering if you intentionally pretend to be ignorant because it's beyond understanding how anyone can end up with both points
there is no censorship in this law, if people don't want to see AI content and as such don't see your content _this is free market selection working as it should, not censorship_, and if people are fine with AI generated content then that is also market selection working as it should. But it gives people a choice.
> That is my point.
your only point is saying bad bad bad without giving any reasoning of how you even ended up at points multiple levels detached from the intend of the law
where does the censorship come from?, because this laws isn't doing censorship
where does the corruption and embezzlement come from? because that argument seem even more detached from reality
pros none? when there is currently a sever risk to democracies based on deep fake propaganda this law would at least reduce, this is clearly not none.
> has no downsides
no one said there are no downsides, you are putting words in other peoples mouths. But this law is basically applying content ingredient laws from e.g. food to AI generated content in a comparatively limited/mundane form.
> Your thinking seems to be dangerously naive to you and people around you.
Then please reason and not throw jumps to conclusions without reasoning at people and then complain that people don't reason with you and if they do just repeat the same jumps without any reasoning and indirectly tell people they are retarded or think dangerously while also using dishonest argumentative practices like taking their "it seems a good idea" and pretending they said "it has no downsides".
Look, there's a ton of places where you can display your AI code, products or comments. Why is it so damn important that no places remain for people who want to be aware of whether or not they are engaging with a human?
Why is it so important to you that users must not be aware?
Even the most ardent AI booster wants their slop to be viewed by human eyeballs, ironically.
Authentic voices are today being drowned in waves upon waves of AI slop spam. This is not quite censorship but the end effect is similar - human voice cannot be heard. Just this time not because someone stopped the human from talking, but because they as shouting 1000x louder instead, at pennies on the dollar it costs to create something truly valuable.
The same way I look at food labels to support local produce and those who don't try to trick me into thinking I am consuming something it's really not.
I personally wouldn't care for AI usage in icons, I don't put a lot of attention to them. Someone else might.
Well, okay, I am not sure how much effort goes into creating your typical stock photo, probably not a lot, just still more than 0 effort it takes for the AI to generate it.
And yes, I see difference between an automated system flooding the web with AI generated "news" in disguise vs a niche blogger using AI to iterate on an image with hand crafted prompts. Labels are not perfect, just better than nothing.
(I also think that labels will quickly become just "background noise" that is mostly ignored.)
Label doesn't prove anything. It just provides a false sense of certainty.
Legacy media uses the argument that consumer already expects to be lied to and knows the content is for entertainment (TV news for example). I feel the same about AI content.
Or should I be expected to blindly trust everything? I already have to critically think and filter everything already so why the distinction? I should try harder for some content and not another? Especially as AI gets better the distinction between AI and no-AI generated content gets blurrier.
All I see is bureaucrats trying to grab more power over people's decisions and more money embezzled. Unelected people forcing rules on their subjects.
It's easy to take yourself out of this equation, but it only makes everything worse. The trick is that they make you think that it couldn't get worse. But this is always false.
With definition of nihilism along the lines of `the rejection of all religious and moral principles, in the belief that life is meaningless`
The point I am making (or trying to) is quite the opposite. Bureaucrats seem to be introducing more violence and even more problems while resolving none. I still have to critically about the content I consume regardless of it having some label. But now tax money goes towards this instead of the things citizens voted for.
As long as it's privately or voluntarily funded and no violence or coercion is used, then I don't really care.
Ensuring democracy by selectively censoring. I feel safer already.
I better put AI label on every video I make as there is already AI in the supply chain of all the tech I use. All content contains AI now.
Let's talk about AI commissars who will decide which company will survive. In fact, let's create a few an NGOs to help! NGO will tell commissar what he wants to hear, NGO will get rewarded and allowed to exist!
I doubt EU will survive the next decade or two without major crisis or war tbh.
Edit: Instead of downvoting, how about you try retorting? I don't think I'm incorrect here. But maybe I am!