But there are also plenty of counterexamples of people who didn't have rich parents, didn't live in good school districts, and did it on their own. I know a person just like that, and she paid for school on her own working fast food shifts at night and full time in the summer, and now has a great job in biotech. $anecdote++;
> you can't see first hand that education really gets you anything.
I don't see that education really does get you anything except a stifled sense of creativity, decreased curiosity, and crushing debt. See: the current college-grad crisis.
"Education" in a modern, western sense is a red herring. Being a lifelong learner, being always curious, and having the desire to do something useful with your life -- if you have these qualities you'll do just fine.
Suppose that we were to play a game - you are given two people, A and B, and the following information about their parents: income level and education level (name of degree/diploma(s) and schools). Do you think that you could come up with a strategy for guessing which person - A or B - will make more money at age 30, that would do better than just flipping a coin?
Formal education does offer you huge benefits. I walked out of school into a job paying many times minimum wage - I got the job because I did well on the interviews, but I got the interviews because I have a degree. Is this fair? Probably not, but it is the reality of the situation. And I do feel like I learned a ton in school. Of course, there are problems with the education system, but that's another discussion.
Is the lesson that parents' education causes this, or that parents who value education/learning produce that type of child? Not to be a "correlation != causation" parrot, but it's worth considering.
Maybe being raised in an environment where participating in "the system" (school, college, salaried job) is the norm produces children who are more likely to participate in the system themselves?
> but I got the interviews because I have a degree
I wouldn't argue against this point on another site, but it should go without saying that here in hacker land this isn't really a thing.
Yes, but those people are playing on "hard" mode, so to speak. More power to them, but it's unreasonable to imply that all people in poor socioeconomic circumstances will be able to do the same.
EDIT (reply to below): Like I said, they're playing on "hard" mode. You cannot expect all or even most people playing on "hard" mode to achieve the same things that people playing on "easy" mode can achieve (people like me living in an affluent suburb, whose parents are upper-middle class, who went to fantastic local schools filled with other upper-middle class students, whose parents can afford to pay for college and any educational expense, etc.)
Why?
First, while it's not entirely a zero-sum game, there's a considerable competitiveness aspect - there aren't enough college slots or scholarships to accommodate everyone getting a good degree from a strong school, and if there were, there wouldn't be enough jobs to hire them into. So at various points, people are going to not make the cut. Do we simply say "well, if you're not in the top X% of the nation you'll have to make do on $10/hour?"
Secondly, because we can't simply wave our wands and make everyone 15-30 IQ points smarter. Getting every poor child to be as motivated and intelligent as that anecdote is at least as large a problem as income inequality generally. It's like saying "I've got a cure for cancer, but it requires time travel" - you've just reduced a Very Hard problem to a different Very Hard problem, which is a solid achievement but doesn't actually solve anything.
EDIT: And Thirdly, why should the answer be that poor people have to work their asses off to catch up just because they made the wrong choice of parents? It's like a race where some contestants have to carry dumbbells - it's great that they can actually succeed, but it's still miles and miles from fair.
False dilemma. The choices are not "either get a good degree from a strong school, or make $10/hour forever".
> we can't simply wave our wands and make everyone 15-30 IQ points smarter
I'm not sure what your point is here.
> why should the answer be that poor people have to work their asses off to catch up just because they made the wrong choice of parents
I wasn't arguing that they should, just that they could.
You're right that it's not yet that stark. Nonetheless, while we need a system which encourages, motivates, and rewards the people who succeed, we also need a system which doesn't abandon the people who don't make the cut. We can't just simply say "well, everyone had a shot" and leave it at that. There are millions of Americans who are working poor, and tens of millions more who are still struggling to get by in the land of plenty.
>I'm not sure what your point is here.
My point is that just because there are ways out for people who are unusually intelligent and unusually diligent doesn't solve the societal inequity, because not everyone can take advantage of those outs unless they suddenly get a lot smarter en masse. Again, even if we perfect meritocracy and all the incentives, we can't ignore the people who don't have IQs over 115 or whatever[1]
[1] - or if IQ is an inadequate measurement, whatever measurement you have for merit.
The world is full of examples like this, but here's the thing that is always glossed over: hard work alone isn't sufficient for success. The kid who grows up on the wrong side of the tracks not only needs to do all the right things, they also need to never do the wrong thing, which typically requires both diligence and luck.
The rich kid who gets caught with drugs? It's a youthful indiscretion, he gets off with a talking to. The poor kid gets a criminal record, which makes it many times harder to succeed.
The rich kid who get pregnant? Her parents pay for an abortion. The poor kid drops out of school to raise the child.
The rich kid who slacks off an flunks a couple classes in high school? Parents pay for some fancy prep school to polish the kids academic record. The poor kid is essentially locked out of top-tier colleges.
The rich kid who doesn't land the Goldman Sachs internship after junior year? Goes to work at his mother's friend's consulting firm and still has something "good" on his resume when he's applying for the first job out of college. The poor kid works at the supermarket.
It's not that being poor means that you can't succeed if you work hard. It's that it means that the deck is stacked against you every step of the way, and that just working hard isn't actually enough even if you do everything right that's in your power to do. You also need to be lucky. If you are sufficiently well-connected and wealthy, however, lots of "minor" things get overlooked and you can be quite successful even if you don't work especially hard and aren't especially lucky.
We'll have good, decently skilled, enthusiastic, hardworking "zero marginal product" people simply because software/robots will be able to do it cheaper than even a subsistence (calories+shelter) wage, and in most tasks employing a human for it would be a senseless luxury.
You can hire a bunch of people to carry you around in a carriage on their backs, or you can hire people to do arithmetics for you - but almost noone does. Soon (in my and your lifetime) the same will be for all the manual, exhausting jobs; for most of the driving, service, cleaning, delivery, and retail jobs; for most of the simple clerical jobs. Even if there is no progress in AI at all, we'll come to a state where, say, 10% of population can cover all major needs (agriculture, food production, service, clothing, construction, consumer goods manufacture, transportation, medical, legal, etc) of everyone. What we'll do with the other 90% (or 99%, or even 100% if AI happens) ? They will be nice, great, fellow humans, but practically speaking, the society can do with them and can do without them. That's a choice for the society - utopias or distopias are both possible.
With trade, there's always relative competitive advantage. It's probably economically more sensible for you the software developer to hire someone to mow your lawn, since you make more money in an hour of writing software than it costs to get someone to mow your lawn. Even if you're better at mowing your lawn than the person you hire - you still make more money writing software (example: You make $100/hour writing software. It takes you 1 hour to mow your lawn, or you can hire someone for 2 hours to do it for you at $20/hour. Opportunity cost to mow the lawn: $200. Gain from hiring someone to mow the lawn: $160. So even though you can mow the lawn twice as fast as the person you hire can, it's still better to hire someone.)
So now it becomes a resourcing problem - you need people who can mow your lawn. Robots can do that, but I don't think that robots can do all jobs at least not in the near future. Which is why I think that a huge part of this is a resourcing problem - you have a mismatch between skills and demand, which again I think is solved through education. Consider software developers again - I bet that if suddenly there was no demand for software developers, any one of us could be successful in another career, since at the heart of it, we're logical thinkers. We need to get as many people to that level as possible.
Furthermore, it's very important to not make poverty generational. I think that I contribute to society through my employment (at least I pay a ton of taxes), but if I wasn't as lucky as I was, I might not be in the same position to do so. I'd still be as capable, at least in terms of potential, but I wouldn't have the opportunity.
The lawnmower example isn't what we're seeing already now - we have structural unemployment of young average people who could and would do simple jobs like mowing lawns, flipping burgers and cleaning sidewalks; but there already are millions more of them than such jobs. And with every year, millions these simple jobs are going away, and unlike all the previous tech-job-shifts, this time the new industries aren't creating new jobs for them. Software developers are hiring other people for lawns and babysitting, but they are currently replacing much more people in "obsolete" industries with high-tech low-headcount disruptive business models.
I do agree with your comments about what's important and how it should be - but it's not really relevant when estimating what will actually be; wishful thinking won't solve it, especially as it's clearly beneficial for the powerful to ignore this problem as long as possible.
Both distopia and utopia is possible, but the distopia is much more likely due to the capitalist system we have, and the rich/poor gap is only going to grow.
If they do have enough reliability to show up on time and enough motivation to go to the community college, there are parts of the country where they can work a minimum wage job and still pay for tuition and a place to stay.
The unemployment problem in unskilled or low skilled labor is largely because government benefits make is economically better for low skilled people to NOT work. In my town there was a waitress who quit her job rather than take on the more hours they wanted her to work because it would have meant losing the money she was getting from the government.
I see a lot of people whose job hunting efforts are minimal or are for jobs they know they aren't qualified for because they want to stay on unemployment. When the unemployment runs out, the real job search will begin.
For a statistical look at this see the book: The Redistribution Recession: How Labor Market Distortions Contracted the Economy
About 15% of Americans are borderline mentally retarded. They are trainable, but most of the suitable jobs have been automated. Finding interesting work for them is a real problem and has gone badly. Currently the welfare apparatus is farming them for votes, but this is not a desirable or sustainable situation.
Also, the distribution is by definition normal, and I have hard time believing 15% of population is retarded. That would mean about 1 in every 6 person I met is retarded, a number too big to believe. Now 3 genius/3 dumb out of 100 is more like what my experience has been.
When your parents are struggling to make ends meet like this, what do you do as a kid? You start working night shifts in high school instead of studying for the SATs.
If you took people in this trap who were willing, and subsidized them for two years to go to community college, I feel like you'd have a huge increase in productivity, especially across generations. And it wouldn't even be that expensive, especially if you factored in increased tax revenue. Or heck, as a lesser goal, make it a goal to enable people making under $X/hour to get their GED.
Maybe this is way too idealistic.
I was lucky. Relatively rich parents, we could move into a good school district, I got to go to a good university, not really worry about money, and now I work in the software industry which is booming. But a huge part of that I owe to circumstance - I could study in school, never hungry, never worried about paying rent.