News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Quiet Wikideath of BBS History by tptacek on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @03:00PM (#4912105)
First, I'm not "defending the deletion of BBS history". It's telling that merely trying to put what's happening on Wikipedia in any kind of balanced perspective counts as taking a side here; it shows how artificially polarized this issue is.

Second, there are clear practical reasons why it would matter if the examples I provided survived as Wikipedia articles:

* The overall perception of Wikipedia's reliability --- which, in reality, is comparable to that of Britannica's for most subjects, and particularly for subjects that are important in the context of traditional encylopedias --- would be sharply diminished.

* The encyclopedia would be full of overtly false information, since no contributor to the project would be able to verify any of the information in those articles.

* Wikipedia would be ruthlessly gamed to get pages to the top of Google SERPs (it already is, and a lot of deletionism over startups and individual people is a reaction to that).

* The project would lose huge amounts of time to mediating squabbles over article name real estate as different garage bands or local volleyball teams argued over which should be the first listed name for their project.

There are no comments on this comment yet.