News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Steel Bank Common Lisp version 2.6.7 by guenthert on Wednesday July 29, 2026 @03:46AM (#49094527)
It is my understanding that easing bootstrap was the original motivation of the fork of CMU CL. I'm a bit confused about that, since CMU CL supports compilation to byte-code (which should make a port to a new architecture comparatively easy), a feature which was dropped in SBCL.
Re:Steel Bank Common Lisp version 2.6.7 by p_l on Wednesday July 29, 2026 @06:07AM (#49095417)
The sane bootstrap is not about porting to new architecture, but about building the compiler from source in the first place. CMU CL effectively requires that you use the same version of CMU CL to build it, IIRC, which in practice meant you had to first load the changes into older CMU CL image - overwriting core components, and then use that image to compile new version.

The difference with SBCL is that it can compile so long as you have any CL implementation that handles certain broad, but not complete, subset of ANSI CL.

It does it by being able to compile itself in sort-of sandboxed state hosted within another CL image, and then using that compiler to build itself, without requiring to modify the host compiler like CMU

As for the bytecode, as far as I recall CMU CL did not have bytecode compiler at all - it had evaluator option, which was indeed dropped for a long time from SBCL but was recently reintroduced, partially to support efforts such as porting Kandria [1] to Nintendo Switch

[1] https://kandria.com/

Re:Steel Bank Common Lisp version 2.6.7 by jhgb on Wednesday July 29, 2026 @11:15AM (#49098620)
> As for the bytecode, as far as I recall CMU CL did not have bytecode compiler at all

The byte code compilation option is described in CMUCL documentation, section 5.9 Byte Coded Compilation: https://cmucl.org/docs/cmu-user/html/Byte-Coded-Compilation....

Re:Steel Bank Common Lisp version 2.6.7 by p_l on Wednesday July 29, 2026 @04:13PM (#49102410)
Ah, with how cmucl was problematic to get running I never delved that deep. It indeed is not present in SBCL.

That said, as mentioned, it gave no real impact on bootstrappability nor portability