Re:Goodbye, Uploads
by jeremymcanally on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @08:28PM
(#4908097)
By the way, downloads of source aren't going away (i.e., get a zip or tar ball)! Just the "upload anything and make it available" feature. There seems to be a little confusion about that.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Goodbye, Uploads
by snogglethorpe on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @08:58PM
(#4908192)
No, most people commenting here seem to perfectly well understand what's going away. An auto-generated repo-contents tarball isn't the same thing as a proper source-distribution tarball.
There's no misunderstanding here. You're removing a feature which a lot of us use and pay for. This sucks.
GitHub is for source code hosting. Not tens to hundreds of MB binary hosting. Put your binaries in s3 and link to them from your project if needed.
They probably determined the excess bloat and strain on their infrastructure from git cloning huge binaries outweighed the benefits so they are removing the feature.
Re:Goodbye, Uploads
by darkarmani on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @11:53PM
(#4908699)
If that is all it is for I might as well host my own git repos too.
The downloads aren't stored in git. They're stored on Amazon S3. Every download link redirects to cloud.github.com, which is fronted by Amazon CloudFront.
Which, conveniently enough, is exactly what they want us to do ourselves now. I already pay GitHub to do that for me, how is it a benefit for me, the paying customer, to do that myself by hand?