The Pirate Bay Is The World’s Most Efficient Public Library

Re:The Pirate Bay Is The World’s Most Efficient Public Library by rada on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @01:33PM (#4905916)

Kind of like a hotel is a physical object but your stay in it is intangible so once you forge the key you are entitled in staying for free? Or kind of like McDonald's brand name is intangible so anyone can open a shack and call it McDonalds without paying a franchise fee?

Seriously, you can make up esoteric arguments ad infinitum and ad absurdum but the fact is, an arbitrary distinction - digital vs. printed - does not a theft unmake. Information wants to be free but books, movies and songs want to sell, or we wouldn't be having this argument.

One last interesting thing for you to ponder: the entire fiction genre is, by definition, misinformation.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:The Pirate Bay Is The World’s Most Efficient Public Library by ShawnBird on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @02:46PM (#4906419)

I said that information is intangible, not that all intangible things are information.

You are being absurd. A physical book and a digital representation of the information are completely different. The only thing that they have in common is that once used you get the same information. If you steal a book, that is theft. If you copy a book that is copyright infringement. The difference is that the person who had the book stolen from then is deprived of property in one example and in the other they are not.

This is not a simple matter. Making a copy is not theft. There are not clear lines here.

[ Parent | on HN ]