Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls'
by btilly on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @03:01PM
(#4906486)
The thing is that the premise that you are accepting, which does underly existing law, is there because of the triumph of an extreme position. (A triumph caused in part because of the creation of the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit.) Therefore accepting that premise is not a neutral position.
As for patents and engineers, I think it is likely that opinions differ. And one of the causes of that difference is that in software it is easy for random non-technical types to create broad patents with little merit by slapping "web" on top of obvious generic ideas. By contrast in hardware, patents are more likely to come from actual devices created by actual engineers, and therefore you tend to have fewer of the truly egregious patent abuses that outrage people on the software side.
Also, I should note that I'm not a patent lawyer. I'm not paid to come to any conclusions on this issue. I have a somewhat more pro-patent outlook than many on HN, but I think it's one that reflects the prevailing view among engineers who have more traditional backgrounds (mine is in defense/wireless communications).