News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do we live in a computer simulation? UW researchers say i... by firlefans on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @01:43AM (#4903393)
Why do smart people love to debate the most implausible nonsense? Time travel through singularities anyone?
Re:Do we live in a computer simulation? UW researchers say i... by the_cat_kittles on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @02:05AM (#4903468)
While I don't know if it's actually deserving of the title "implausible nonsense", I think its important to remember that stupid is as stupid does, and same goes for smart. Someone isn't smart because they have the trappings of intelligence, its because they did something smart.
Re:Do we live in a computer simulation? UW researchers say i... by firlefans on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @05:11AM (#4903890)
"its because they did something smart" So intelligence == 'achievement'? That makes no sense.

As for nonsense, ok I'll retract that, it is an interesting but highly implausible topic that gets a large amount of discussion relative to it's likelihood. It's actually just another way of phrasing "Does God exist?" If there was a computer (God) simulating this universe and controlling it, then it'd require a host universe for itself to exist, and it's complexity has to be greater than what it is simulating. Therefore it is less likely, and not by an insignificant amount.

Re:Do we live in a computer simulation? UW researchers say i... by the_cat_kittles on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @09:25PM (#4908289)
I guess its true that you can't just equate intelligence with achievement. In my own life, I think I've increasingly used achievement where I used to use intelligence to gauge how 'smart' someone is. That comment was also trying to get at the annoyingly pervasive belief people seem to have that you must be smart because you are a mathematician, say. As an example, novices might think someone is good at basketball based on how they look on the court- but you wouldn't say someone is good unless they actually had a big positive effect on how often their team won. In general, I guess when I say smart, I mean "good" in some abstract sense.