News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Couple pay >$800k for a gene-editing therapy for their da... by decimalenough on Thursday July 23, 2026 @07:20PM (#49029397)
If he had succeeded, though, he would have been a hero, both to the parents and the world. And the same racing that we are condemning as monstrous would have saved other children as well.

Obviously I'm not saying he is a hero or that what he did is right, just pointing out that the ethical tradeoffs in medical research like this get very complicated very fast. Ultimately it boils down to the trolley problem: is sacrificing a few worth saving many others?

Re:Couple pay >$800k for a gene-editing therapy for their da... by MSKJ on Thursday July 23, 2026 @07:27PM (#49029461)
It doesn't seem like success was of particular import to the doctor, rather the goal seems to have been to get a 'test subject'
Re:Couple pay >$800k for a gene-editing therapy for their da... by 0dayz on Thursday July 23, 2026 @09:19PM (#49030218)
Not exactly, trolley problem is about a sacrifice, in this case the idea is no sacrifice, because failure is absolute, especially in that you gain nothing, Quis research is as useless to cite as Dr He, yes they both used certain scientific approaches, but clearly skipped medical and ethical concerns.